Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
design
stringclasses
4 values
series
stringlengths
18
40
n
int64
50
16k
T_pre
float64
2
8
⌀
phi
float64
0
0.8
⌀
rho_hat
float64
0
2.1
cov_at_pow50
float64
0
0.85
⌀
cov_at_pow80
float64
0
0.72
⌀
min_cov_undetected
float64
0
0.92
max_b
float64
2.03
6.81
size_at_0
float64
0.01
0.06
cov_at_0
float64
0.94
0.96
visible
bool
2 classes
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
50
4
0.5
0.865622
0.382923
0.124015
0.4725
6.06306
0.0505
0.946
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
2
0
0.784308
0.284276
0.067393
0.289
6.002812
0.053
0.9555
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
2
0.5
1.014095
0.506134
0.221308
0.68
6.015377
0.0445
0.946
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
2
0.8
1.205042
0.626012
0.359596
0.6835
6.015895
0.058
0.945
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
4
0
0.795364
0.284454
0.081389
0.291
6.045765
0.0535
0.9445
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
4
0.5
0.902546
0.384321
0.132541
0.457
6.01267
0.0545
0.949
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
4
0.8
1.010348
0.485389
0.222056
0.49
5.979749
0.058
0.9445
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
8
0
0.726903
0.221622
0.051604
0.2905
5.972905
0.0445
0.951
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
8
0.5
0.793078
0.289266
0.081119
0.3205
5.994543
0.05
0.948
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
200
8
0.8
0.891573
0.365597
0.134558
0.479
6.001675
0.0415
0.952
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, Ashenfelter dip
1,000
4
0.5
0.906701
0.40994
0.136183
0.5055
5.973886
0.0535
0.946
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
50
4
0.5
0
null
null
0
6.045757
0.0445
0.9625
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
2
0
0
null
null
0
6.045124
0.052
0.944
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
2
0.5
0
null
null
0
5.982204
0.0535
0.9505
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
2
0.8
0
null
null
0
6.006216
0.048
0.9455
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
4
0
0
null
null
0
5.996461
0.041
0.951
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
4
0.5
0
null
null
0
5.966587
0.0455
0.944
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
4
0.8
0
null
null
0
6.015918
0.0435
0.9515
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
8
0
0
null
null
0.0005
5.991993
0.0515
0.9525
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
8
0.5
0
null
null
0
6.012465
0.044
0.95
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
200
8
0.8
0
null
null
0
6.039072
0.0485
0.9535
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, coincident shock
1,000
4
0.5
0
null
null
0
6.024727
0.047
0.956
false
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
50
4
0.5
0.72425
0.244814
0.050018
0.302
5.994866
0.048
0.9495
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
2
0
0.317035
null
null
0
5.991463
0.0495
0.9415
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
2
0.5
0.409153
0.006615
null
0.0215
6.025185
0.0475
0.9565
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
2
0.8
0.489615
0.028751
0.000263
0.152
6.04161
0.054
0.9495
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
4
0
0.823478
0.282817
0.094516
0.4935
5.985198
0.047
0.953
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
4
0.5
0.769066
0.267704
0.066
0.3055
6.032939
0.047
0.9485
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
4
0.8
0.759469
0.244666
0.069853
0.276
5.968629
0.0485
0.9435
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
8
0
2.101515
0.849662
0.716051
0.919
6.023116
0.045
0.9485
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
8
0.5
1.510561
0.726713
0.551866
0.8265
6.035268
0.047
0.955
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
200
8
0.8
1.208059
0.600307
0.383981
0.6685
6.003167
0.0545
0.9575
true
Difference-in-differences
pre-trend test, linear trend
1,000
4
0.5
0.764474
0.266975
0.064969
0.295
5.966084
0.049
0.954
true
Instrumental variables
J test, one invalid instrument
500
null
null
0.79175
0.297906
0.094679
0.3935
6.513179
0.0505
0.9505
true
Instrumental variables
J test, one invalid instrument
2,000
null
null
0.79955
0.308935
0.09203
0.3895
6.705172
0.0575
0.9525
true
Instrumental variables
J test, one invalid instrument
10,000
null
null
0.793812
0.303844
0.090695
0.3925
6.811817
0.056
0.9395
true
Instrumental variables
J test, proportional violation
500
null
null
0
null
null
0
6.775496
0.056
0.945
false
Instrumental variables
J test, proportional violation
2,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
6.795342
0.0465
0.9505
false
Instrumental variables
J test, proportional violation
10,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
6.752118
0.0545
0.947
false
Instrumental variables
first-stage F < 10
500
null
null
0
null
null
0.001
5.297173
0.009
0.9505
false
Instrumental variables
first-stage F < 10
2,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
5.33959
0.0115
0.9575
false
Instrumental variables
first-stage F < 10
10,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
5.331685
0.011
0.9525
false
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=0$
500
null
null
0
null
null
0.001
5.297173
0.058
0.9505
false
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=0$
2,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
5.33959
0.048
0.9575
false
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=0$
10,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
5.331685
0.046
0.9525
false
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=0.5$
500
null
null
0.185804
null
null
0.001
5.297173
0.058
0.9505
true
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=0.5$
2,000
null
null
0.174053
null
null
0
5.33959
0.048
0.9575
true
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=0.5$
10,000
null
null
0.174957
null
null
0
5.331685
0.046
0.9525
true
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=1$
500
null
null
0.346583
0.001
null
0.001
5.297173
0.058
0.9505
true
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=1$
2,000
null
null
0.338492
0.000484
null
0
5.33959
0.048
0.9575
true
Instrumental variables
zero-first-stage group, $\phi=1$
10,000
null
null
0.332566
0.000011
null
0.0005
5.331685
0.046
0.9525
true
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, one-sided sorting
1,000
null
null
0.67583
null
null
0.47
2.0335
0.047
0.952
true
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, one-sided sorting
4,000
null
null
0.666358
0.147091
null
0.233
3.527956
0.038
0.942
true
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, one-sided sorting
16,000
null
null
0.668993
0.169811
null
0.312
4.102021
0.035
0.954
true
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, two-sided sorting on $U$
1,000
null
null
0.652297
0.174984
null
0.312
3.681616
0.045
0.939
true
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, two-sided sorting on $U$
4,000
null
null
0.659739
0.181905
0.012835
0.226
4.565134
0.052
0.946
true
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, two-sided sorting on $U$
16,000
null
null
0.669188
0.191767
0.011755
0.233
4.776853
0.046
0.947
true
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, two-sided sorting on $V$
1,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.121
3.111668
0.05
0.945
false
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, two-sided sorting on $V$
4,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.013
4.177501
0.053
0.957
false
Regression discontinuity
covariate test, two-sided sorting on $V$
16,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.005
4.664646
0.062
0.936
false
Regression discontinuity
density test, one-sided sorting
1,000
null
null
0.73961
0.507746
null
0.47
2.0335
0.053
0.952
true
Regression discontinuity
density test, one-sided sorting
4,000
null
null
0.4673
null
null
0.067
3.527956
0.057
0.942
true
Regression discontinuity
density test, one-sided sorting
16,000
null
null
0.401384
null
null
0.023
4.102021
0.05
0.954
true
Regression discontinuity
density test, two-sided sorting on $U$
1,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.046
3.681616
0.06
0.939
true
Regression discontinuity
density test, two-sided sorting on $U$
4,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.008
4.565134
0.056
0.946
true
Regression discontinuity
density test, two-sided sorting on $U$
16,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.002
4.776853
0.05
0.947
true
Regression discontinuity
density test, two-sided sorting on $V$
1,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.121
3.111668
0.05
0.945
false
Regression discontinuity
density test, two-sided sorting on $V$
4,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.013
4.177501
0.041
0.957
false
Regression discontinuity
density test, two-sided sorting on $V$
16,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.005
4.664646
0.055
0.936
false
Regression discontinuity
either test, one-sided sorting
1,000
null
null
0.821426
0.508897
null
0.47
2.0335
0.047
0.952
true
Regression discontinuity
either test, one-sided sorting
4,000
null
null
0.676663
0.178338
null
0.233
3.527956
0.054
0.942
true
Regression discontinuity
either test, one-sided sorting
16,000
null
null
0.649496
0.147039
null
0.155
4.102021
0.042
0.954
true
Regression discontinuity
either test, two-sided sorting on $U$
1,000
null
null
0.570986
0.071714
null
0.085
3.681616
0.057
0.939
true
Regression discontinuity
either test, two-sided sorting on $U$
4,000
null
null
0.587126
0.086217
null
0.226
4.565134
0.037
0.946
true
Regression discontinuity
either test, two-sided sorting on $U$
16,000
null
null
0.603943
0.100301
0.005758
0.233
4.776853
0.053
0.947
true
Regression discontinuity
either test, two-sided sorting on $V$
1,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.121
3.111668
0.054
0.945
false
Regression discontinuity
either test, two-sided sorting on $V$
4,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.013
4.177501
0.049
0.957
false
Regression discontinuity
either test, two-sided sorting on $V$
16,000
null
null
0
null
null
0.005
4.664646
0.055
0.936
false
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=0$
500
null
null
0
null
null
0
5.504087
0.052
0.9485
false
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=0$
2,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
5.841247
0.0485
0.9425
false
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=0$
10,000
null
null
0
null
null
0
5.929053
0.055
0.947
false
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=0.5$
500
null
null
0.625239
0.148711
0.008695
0.1775
5.504087
0.0555
0.9485
true
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=0.5$
2,000
null
null
0.629439
0.141307
0.01135
0.1645
5.841247
0.047
0.9425
true
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=0.5$
10,000
null
null
0.639041
0.156499
0.01094
0.164
5.929053
0.0575
0.947
true
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=1$
500
null
null
0.99573
0.482666
0.199253
0.4885
5.504087
0.051
0.9485
true
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=1$
2,000
null
null
1.003744
0.490856
0.208287
0.6985
5.841247
0.0475
0.9425
true
Selection on observables
placebo outcome, $\kappa=1$
10,000
null
null
0.990324
0.496717
0.193732
0.6715
5.929053
0.0525
0.947
true
Selection on observables
placebo, $\kappa=1$, high noise
500
null
null
0.625239
0.148711
0.008695
0.1775
5.504087
0.0555
0.9485
true
Selection on observables
placebo, $\kappa=1$, high noise
2,000
null
null
0.629439
0.141307
0.01135
0.1645
5.841247
0.047
0.9425
true
Selection on observables
placebo, $\kappa=1$, high noise
10,000
null
null
0.639041
0.156499
0.01094
0.164
5.929053
0.0575
0.947
true
Selection on observables
placebo, $\kappa=1$, low noise
500
null
null
1.268392
0.655719
0.390304
0.689
5.504087
0.049
0.9485
true
Selection on observables
placebo, $\kappa=1$, low noise
2,000
null
null
1.267933
0.654267
0.38741
0.6985
5.841247
0.044
0.9425
true
Selection on observables
placebo, $\kappa=1$, low noise
10,000
null
null
1.265481
0.64726
0.389663
0.6715
5.929053
0.049
0.947
true

The Identification Gap — results

Every simulation and empirical result behind the preprint The Identification Gap: What Diagnostic Tests Can and Cannot Reveal About Causal Research Designs (Thanatchon Chongmankhong, November 2026).

The paper asks what a passed diagnostic test (placebo outcome, overidentification, pre-trends, density or covariate continuity) actually certifies. For a violation that moves the estimator and the diagnostic linearly, everything depends on the estimator's standardised bias b and the detectability ratio ρ = ν / b.

Files

Each CSV is its own config: load_dataset("thanatchon36/identification-gap", "simA_did").

Config Content
emp_card_chr Card (1995): Conley–Hansen–Rossi bounds over γ_max
emp_castle_eventstudy castle doctrine event-study coefficients
emp_castle_rm castle doctrine relative-magnitudes bounds
emp_lalonde LaLonde (NSW) estimates, placebo tests and standardised bias vs experimental benchmark
emp_prop99_gaps Proposition 99 synthetic-control gaps by state and year
emp_rdd_covariates House/Senate RDD covariate-continuity tests
plasmode plasmode simulations on LaLonde–PSID and castle-doctrine covariates
plasmode_info plasmode design metadata
simA_did Experiment A: difference-in-differences, controlled violations
simA_iv Experiment A: instrumental variables, controlled violations
simA_rdd Experiment A: regression discontinuity, controlled violations
simA_soo Experiment A: selection on observables, controlled violations
simB_fixable Experiment B: five estimation problems, naive vs modern estimators
simC_sensitivity Experiment C: coverage and relative width of six sensitivity analyses
summary_series detectability ratio ρ̂ and coverage at 50/80% power for every simulated series
theory_certification power to certify
theory_frontier coverage–power frontier: coverage and diagnostic power over (ρ, b)
theory_literature coverage after a pre-test, averaged over a literature of violations
theory_mc_verification Monte Carlo check of the closed forms (2×10⁵ draws per cell)
theory_pretest unconditional vs conditional (on passing) coverage over (r, ρ, b)
theory_table coverage at 50/80/90% diagnostic power and certification power, by ρ

JSON files in results/ hold scalar summaries (theory_key_numbers.json, emp_*.json).

Common columns in the simulation tables: R replications, bias, sd, mean_se, rmse, b (bias / sd), coverage (of the nominal 95% CI) with coverage_mcse, power_* (rejection rate of a diagnostic), pass_* (share passing), cov_pass_* (coverage conditional on passing).

Reproduce

git clone https://github.com/thanatchon36/identification-gap && cd identification-gap
pip install -r requirements.txt
bash run_all.sh   # about 15 minutes on one core; rewrites results/ and rebuilds the paper

Raw data

The empirical inputs are public replication datasets and are not redistributed here; get them from their sources: LaLonde/NSW (Imbens & Xu 2024, xuyiqing/lalonde), Card (1995) (Wooldridge data via Rdatasets), castle doctrine and Lee–Moretti–Butler (Cunningham, Causal Inference: The Mixtape), Senate RDD (rdrobust), Proposition 99 (synthdid).

Citation

@misc{chongmankhong2026identification,
  author = {Chongmankhong, Thanatchon},
  title  = {The Identification Gap: What Diagnostic Tests Can and Cannot Reveal About Causal Research Designs},
  year   = {2026},
  note   = {Preprint},
  doi    = {10.5281/zenodo.24243854},
  url    = {https://github.com/thanatchon36/identification-gap}
}
Downloads last month
84