{
  "schema_version": "1.0.0",
  "item_id": "HF-PP-2026-W10",
  "scenario_id": "failure_scenario_002",
  "title": "The citation passed. The evidence was stale",
  "scenario_kind": "synthetic",
  "created_on": "2026-10-22",
  "timezone": "Europe/Kyiv",
  "review": {
    "kind": "ROOT_AI_REVIEW",
    "human_approval_claimed": false,
    "user_authorization": "\u0433\u043e\u0442\u043e\u0432\u044c \u0438 \u043f\u0443\u0431\u043b\u0438\u043a\u0443\u0439 Failure Scenario 002",
    "scope": "Synthetic fixture behavior, English reference text and additive packaging; not operational source verification"
  },
  "dataset_id": "pharosproduction/production-ai-control-evidence",
  "config": "failure_scenario_002",
  "split": "synthetic",
  "rows": 10,
  "predecessor_dataset_revision": "efbf09235d54f8e08426ef0f2e34935d603e01e9",
  "original_control_count": 55,
  "previous_scenario_rows": 10,
  "preserved_original_files": 23,
  "source_methods": [
    {
      "repo": "rag-vs-fine-tuning-matrix",
      "revision": "6ea24ef75c3ad09a3bb76d1c20a173bfab592559",
      "path": "data/rules.json",
      "sha256": "2e7e1cc3602086eccdced9d531ae327fc9d17f1d7e09e9b7f431c918e6627d83",
      "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/PharosProduction/rag-vs-fine-tuning-matrix/6ea24ef75c3ad09a3bb76d1c20a173bfab592559/data/rules.json",
      "selected_records": [
        {
          "id": "RULE-BLOCKED-NO-RETRIEVAL-OPS",
          "kind": "decision",
          "priority": 50,
          "outcomeId": "BLOCKED",
          "when": {
            "all": [
              {
                "criterionId": "authoritative_corpus",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "yes"
              },
              {
                "criterionId": "retrieval_operations",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "no"
              }
            ],
            "any": [
              {
                "criterionId": "fresh_facts",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "yes"
              },
              {
                "criterionId": "source_citations",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "yes"
              }
            ]
          },
          "disqualifiers": [
            "NO_RETRIEVAL_OPERATING_PATH"
          ],
          "rejectedOutcomes": [
            "RAG",
            "HYBRID"
          ],
          "nextSteps": [
            "Assign ownership for ingestion, index freshness, retrieval evaluation, rollback, and access control."
          ],
          "sourceIds": [
            "SOURCE-MICROSOFT-RAG-VS-FT"
          ],
          "claimIds": [
            "CLAIM-CORPUS-QUALITY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "id": "RULE-RAG-CANDIDATE",
          "kind": "decision",
          "priority": 80,
          "outcomeId": "RAG",
          "when": {
            "all": [
              {
                "criterionId": "authoritative_corpus",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "yes"
              },
              {
                "criterionId": "retrieval_operations",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "yes"
              }
            ],
            "any": [
              {
                "criterionId": "fresh_facts",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "yes"
              },
              {
                "criterionId": "source_citations",
                "operator": "equals",
                "value": "yes"
              }
            ]
          },
          "nextSteps": [
            "Build a retrieval baseline and evaluate passage relevance, claim support, answer quality, freshness, and recovery from stale indexes."
          ],
          "sourceIds": [
            "SOURCE-RAG-PAPER",
            "SOURCE-MICROSOFT-RAG-VS-FT"
          ],
          "claimIds": [
            "CLAIM-RAG-RUNTIME-RETRIEVAL",
            "CLAIM-RAG-FRESHNESS-FIT",
            "CLAIM-RAG-PROVENANCE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "repo": "agent-security-control-mapper",
      "revision": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee",
      "path": "data/controls.json",
      "sha256": "a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6",
      "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json",
      "selected_records": [
        {
          "id": "CTL-MEMORY-VALIDATION",
          "layerId": "memory-integrity",
          "order": 2,
          "name": "Memory write validation and provenance",
          "objective": "Keep untrusted, contradictory or malformed content from silently becoming persistent decision context.",
          "functions": [
            "prevent",
            "detect",
            "contain"
          ],
          "implementation": "Validate memory schemas, retain source and writer identity, classify trust, detect conflicting high-impact facts and quarantine suspicious writes before retrieval.",
          "verification": "Submit malformed, untrusted, contradictory and cross-scope memories; confirm rejection or quarantine and retained provenance.",
          "evidenceArtifacts": [
            "Memory schema and trust policy",
            "Poisoning test corpus results",
            "Quarantine queue sample"
          ],
          "suggestedOwnerRole": "AI data security owner",
          "releaseGateWhenRequired": true,
          "standardRefs": [
            "C8.2.1",
            "C8.2.3",
            "C8.2.4",
            "C8.2.5"
          ],
          "sourceIds": [
            "S01",
            "S03",
            "S04",
            "S12"
          ],
          "claimIds": [
            "C08",
            "C09",
            "C20"
          ]
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "files": {
    "README.md": "85179e643a92a03960651d199b8512fb69b82f22cdd72b82ff526f5e768fe17b",
    "SCENARIO-002.md": "0c77f060e066fe2e1c9758a670ab92c7161cbb64341b37d6b769bb555ca23e35",
    "failure-scenario-002.jsonl": "5c0baa451105fcf3c830b36a441c9604cdd72d2d13c9d3188f2a8548cfb179f1",
    "scenario-002-evaluator.mjs": "b2319b040cde0b23415b72e8a21cf445c6fe618085e841c4338e25d30bc915a1",
    "scenario-002-tests.mjs": "fd21d8ca3d5bbd1f6e89428dcc0c4b84cfe2195db701d7e03065df8b19a1c266",
    "scenario-002.schema.json": "6de772f4d3108d0ad1f0d57105e30cbbcb5b48fc95526f7e917c3c0b1cbd5f53"
  },
  "checks": {
    "local_unchanged_suite": {
      "passed": 17,
      "failed": 0,
      "honest_red": true
    },
    "public_reproduction_suite": {
      "passed": 16,
      "failed": 0
    },
    "root_builder_after_visible_scope_copy": {
      "passed": 1,
      "failed": 0
    },
    "scenario_001_predecessor": {
      "matched": 10,
      "unchanged": true
    },
    "json_schema": {
      "valid_rows": 10,
      "draft": "2020-12"
    },
    "fixture_outcomes": {
      "fixture_sha256": "5c0baa451105fcf3c830b36a441c9604cdd72d2d13c9d3188f2a8548cfb179f1",
      "matched": 10,
      "results": [
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-01",
          "expected": "HOLD_STALE",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_STALE",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": 504,
            "reasons": [
              "The cited passage age exceeds the supplied illustrative maximum age."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-02",
          "expected": "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE",
          "result": {
            "code": "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": 1,
            "reasons": [
              "The supplied fixture passes exact citation, source-state, revision, verification, age, claim and conflict checks. This is not real answer-release permission."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-03",
          "expected": "HOLD_CONTRADICTION",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_CONTRADICTION",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": 1,
            "reasons": [
              "Fresh supplied passages contain differing exact values for the same claim key; no passage is automatically selected."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-04",
          "expected": "HOLD_REVISION_MISMATCH",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_REVISION_MISMATCH",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": 1,
            "reasons": [
              "The cited revision differs from the supplied current source revision."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-05",
          "expected": "HOLD_CITATION",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_CITATION",
            "citation_check": "FAIL",
            "age_hours": null,
            "reasons": [
              "The citation must resolve to exactly one supplied source, revision and passage."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-06",
          "expected": "HOLD_UNVERIFIED",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_UNVERIFIED",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": 1,
            "reasons": [
              "At least one supplied passage for the claim key is unverified."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-07",
          "expected": "HOLD_INVALID_INPUT",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_INVALID_INPUT",
            "citation_check": "NOT_CHECKED",
            "age_hours": null,
            "reasons": [
              "Input must match the closed synthetic schema, scalar bounds and real UTC calendar timestamps."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-08",
          "expected": "HOLD_FUTURE",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_FUTURE",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": -1,
            "reasons": [
              "At least one relevant passage has a timestamp later than the fixed evaluation time."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-09",
          "expected": "HOLD_CLAIM_MISMATCH",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_CLAIM_MISMATCH",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": 1,
            "reasons": [
              "The proposed exact claim key or value differs from the cited passage."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        },
        {
          "case_id": "FS002-10",
          "expected": "HOLD_SOURCE_STATE",
          "result": {
            "code": "HOLD_SOURCE_STATE",
            "citation_check": "PASS",
            "age_hours": 1,
            "reasons": [
              "The supplied current source snapshot is absent or refers to a different source."
            ],
            "answer_released": false,
            "release_eligible": false
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    "local_browser": {
      "baseline_citation_check": "PASS",
      "baseline_code": "HOLD_STALE",
      "age_hours": 504,
      "actual_json_download_verified": true
    },
    "ohvat": {
      "overall": "PARTIAL_CONTEXT_LIMITATIONS",
      "gist_lint_findings": 0,
      "gist_summary": "PROVISIONAL PASS",
      "competitor_replaceability": "SKIPPED_NO_COMPETITOR_INPUTS",
      "ai_tells": "NO_FAIL_INTENTIONAL_FLAGS",
      "semantic_standalone_rendered": "PASS_0_FINDINGS"
    }
  },
  "limits": [
    "All recovery values and source documents are invented synthetic fixtures.",
    "Current-source revision and verification status are supplied fields, not authenticated evidence.",
    "Exact claim-key/value comparison does not detect semantic prose contradictions or missing documents.",
    "No retrieval, model evaluation, client incident, production authorization or answer release.",
    "Illustrative48hour policy is not an industry standard."
  ],
  "answer_released": false,
  "release_eligible": false
}