{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "authority-mismatch", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "DENY_ACTION_SCOPE", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.read\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"granted\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-16T00:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "The request action does not exactly match the authority action.", "observed_outcome": "DENY_ACTION_SCOPE", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "scoped-correction", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"granted\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-16T00:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "None within this synthetic comparison.", "observed_outcome": "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "missing-authority", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "HOLD_MISSING_AUTHORITY", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": null, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "No authority record was supplied.", "observed_outcome": "HOLD_MISSING_AUTHORITY", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "expired-authority", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "HOLD_NOT_CURRENT", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"granted\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-15T08:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "The fixed evaluation time is outside the authority interval [valid_from, valid_until).", "observed_outcome": "HOLD_NOT_CURRENT", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "wrong-principal", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "DENY_PRINCIPAL_SCOPE", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"other-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"granted\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-16T00:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "The request principal does not exactly match the authority principal.", "observed_outcome": "DENY_PRINCIPAL_SCOPE", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "wrong-tenant", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "DENY_TENANT_SCOPE", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"granted\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-other-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-16T00:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "The request tenant does not exactly match the authority tenant.", "observed_outcome": "DENY_TENANT_SCOPE", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "wrong-resource", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "DENY_RESOURCE_SCOPE", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:OTHER-001\", \"status\": \"granted\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-16T00:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "The request resource does not exactly match the authority resource.", "observed_outcome": "DENY_RESOURCE_SCOPE", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "unverified-authority", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "HOLD_UNVERIFIED_AUTHORITY", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"unknown\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-16T00:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "The supplied authority status is unverified.", "observed_outcome": "HOLD_UNVERIFIED_AUTHORITY", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "invalid-authority", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "HOLD_INVALID_INPUT", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"granted\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"not-a-timestamp\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "Required fields, explicit UTC timestamps and a positive authority interval must be valid.", "observed_outcome": "HOLD_INVALID_INPUT", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}
{"action_executed": false, "case_id": "explicit-denial", "correction": "Ask the authorized policy owner to review the exact invocation and current grant. Editing this fixture creates no real permission.", "evidence_status": "EXECUTED_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE", "expected_control_ids": ["CTL-POLICY-DECISION", "CTL-TENANT-BOUNDARY", "CTL-TOOL-AUTH"], "expected_outcome": "DENY_EXPLICIT", "input_json": "{\"as_of\": \"2026-10-15T09:00:00Z\", \"authority\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"status\": \"denied\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\", \"valid_from\": \"2026-10-15T00:00:00Z\", \"valid_until\": \"2026-10-16T00:00:00Z\"}, \"request\": {\"action\": \"ticket.close\", \"principal\": \"support-agent-demo\", \"resource\": \"ticket:DEMO-001\", \"tenant\": \"tenant-demo\"}}", "limitations": ["Fictional inputs and policy grants; no client incident or model evaluation.", "No tool call, signature validation or real authorization service.", "ALLOW_IN_FIXTURE is an illustrative comparison result, not production permission."], "model_result_status": "CORRECT_BY_FIXTURE_DEFINITION_NO_MODEL_RUN", "observed_failure": "The supplied authority explicitly denies the request.", "observed_outcome": "DENY_EXPLICIT", "release_eligible": false, "scenario_id": "FS-001", "scenario_kind": "synthetic", "source_commit_sha": "a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee", "source_dataset_revision": "4d8d23ca7ff15db763b7c1ef7513dfade30098e4", "source_kind": "original_synthetic_fixture", "source_url": "https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json", "stop_condition": "Do not dispatch the action unless the real enforcement service authorizes the exact invocation under current policy."}