Hugging Face's logo

Datasets:
pharosproduction
/
production-ai-control-evidence

Modalities:
Text
Formats:
json
Languages:
English
Size:
< 1K
Tags:
production-ai
decision-support
provenance
draft
Synthetic
authorization
Libraries:
Datasets
pandas
Polars
Dataset card Data Studio Files
xet
 Community
1
production-ai-control-evidence / failure-scenario-003.jsonl
dmytro-nasyrov's picture
dmytro-nasyrov
Publish Failure Scenario 003 and additive scenario bundle v1.1
e0f9112 verified
Raw History Blame
27.3 kB
{"case_id":"FS003-01","case_name":"candidate-drops-evidence","correction":"Retain the failed output and revise the candidate or adapter, then rerun the same fixture.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"HOLD_OUTPUT_SCHEMA","expected_comparison":"CONTROL_REGRESSION","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Candidate omits a required evidence field although prompt and evaluation bindings match.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-02","case_name":"candidate-changes-amount","correction":"Check the exact amount field; schema validity alone is insufficient.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"HOLD_AMOUNT","expected_comparison":"CONTROL_REGRESSION","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":1250,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Both outputs fit the shape, but candidate changes12500minor units to1250.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-03","case_name":"candidate-changes-tenant","correction":"Reject the substituted context and rerun exact-scope checks.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"HOLD_TENANT_SCOPE","expected_comparison":"CONTROL_REGRESSION","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"other-tenant"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Candidate substitutes the supplied tenant identity.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-04","case_name":"candidate-changes-evidence","correction":"Compare the evidence identifier with the fixed evaluation record.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"HOLD_EVIDENCE","expected_comparison":"CONTROL_REGRESSION","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-099","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Candidate cites another synthetic evidence record.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-05","case_name":"candidate-changes-decision","correction":"Preserve the supplied expected decision; passing output still creates no action authority.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"HOLD_DECISION","expected_comparison":"CONTROL_REGRESSION","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"RELEASE","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Candidate changes the expected HOLD field to RELEASE.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-06","case_name":"corrected-pair","correction":"Retain exact input/output hashes and repeat evaluation for another revision.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"PASS_IN_FIXTURE","expected_comparison":"NO_REGRESSION_IN_FIXTURE","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"No mismatch in the supplied pair. This does not validate either fictional model.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-07","case_name":"different-prompt-binding","correction":"Use the same exact prompt and retain its computed digest for both snapshots.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"NOT_CHECKED","expected_comparison":"HOLD_PROMPT_BINDING","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Candidate snapshot does not bind to the supplied prompt bytes.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-08","case_name":"different-evaluation-binding","correction":"Use one exact evaluation record; do not compare results from different inputs.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"NOT_CHECKED","expected_comparison":"HOLD_EVAL_BINDING","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Candidate snapshot does not bind to the fixed evaluation record.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-09","case_name":"failed-baseline","correction":"Repair or explicitly replace the baseline and repeat the same control check.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"PASS_IN_FIXTURE","expected_comparison":"HOLD_BASELINE_FAILURE","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"USD","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_B","model_revision":"demo-b-r2","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Baseline already fails the currency check; a candidate comparison cannot establish a clean baseline.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}
{"case_id":"FS003-10","case_name":"same-model-identity","correction":"Provide two distinct explicitly identified fixture revisions.","evidence_status":"AUTHORED_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUT_PAIR_NOT_MODEL_EXECUTION","expected_candidate_control":"NOT_CHECKED","expected_comparison":"HOLD_MODEL_IDENTITY","input":{"baseline":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"candidate":{"evaluation_sha256":"4eaf8794cb3cfcf38646bf196ec0d30855b780fb9e9f46e410af83d07e2e2df3","model_id":"SYNTHETIC_MODEL_A","model_revision":"demo-a-r1","output":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"prompt_sha256":"41187f6cf9a04fd6ef89ba8adfa3e75082b4abdceed84dfbf1ba956899b085ef"},"evaluation_input":{"amount_minor":12500,"currency":"EUR","decision":"HOLD","evidence_id":"E-DEMO-042","record_id":"REVIEW-DEMO-042","tenant_id":"tenant-demo"},"policy_revision":"synthetic-control-v1","prompt":{"prompt_id":"PROMPT-DEMO-003","text":"Return the supplied review record as JSON with record_id, tenant_id, amount_minor, currency, evidence_id and decision. Preserve every supplied value. This is a fictional review record; do not release an action."}},"limitations":["Both model identities, revisions and outputs are fictional fixtures. No inference or client incident.","Exact field equality is not semantic answer-quality, model accuracy or operating-effectiveness evidence.","Hashes identify supplied bytes; they do not authenticate model execution or source truth."],"model_execution_status":"NOT_RUN_SYNTHETIC_OUTPUTS","observed_failure":"Both snapshot model identity tuples are identical, so this is not a revision-change comparison.","scenario_id":"failure_scenario_003","scenario_kind":"synthetic","source_commit_sha":"a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee","source_control_ids":["CTL-OUTPUT-SCHEMA","DRIFT-SCHEMA"],"source_data_hash":"sha256:a50333997f3f9832df16329f27d8e5be608c50ba1dffea0282ee1b1eff0956a6","source_dataset_revision":"c456a821e587362c95dadc86a3ac722de78179da","source_kind":"original_synthetic_fixture","source_url":"https://github.com/PharosProduction/agent-security-control-mapper/blob/a35b9c30594162eadf4d790d33bd18aaa785bcee/data/controls.json","stop_condition":"A regression, failed baseline or unaligned input holds this comparison. A passing synthetic pair never approves a model or a production release."}