diff --git "a/data/h3_causal_icl_v1/quality/train.pair_screening.jsonl" "b/data/h3_causal_icl_v1/quality/train.pair_screening.jsonl"
new file mode 100644--- /dev/null
+++ "b/data/h3_causal_icl_v1/quality/train.pair_screening.jsonl"
@@ -0,0 +1,65 @@
+{"pair_id": "cr_9b35ac1328c468c7de29", "query_id": "999faf30bd6a0eb9cd37a4065a6334df54be6f023de44f366cecddd4ee97789b", "demo_id": "fa86f8cffb1b464bb5afe274cfa526a87d40333e1c0dc6ccf9bb9046ff41c3c0", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/999faf30bd6a0eb9cd37a4065a6334df54be6f023de44f366cecddd4ee97789b.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/fa86f8cffb1b464bb5afe274cfa526a87d40333e1c0dc6ccf9bb9046ff41c3c0.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_9b35ac1328c468c7de29", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.3827, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A red-headed hammer is crushed by a descending metal cylinder, causing deformation and fragmentation of the hammer head.", "demo_event": "A pile of colorful, ring-shaped candies is compressed and crushed by a descending hydraulic press, causing them to break and scatter.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid or brittle object is subjected to a high-force, downward-acting compression from a descending mass, it undergoes structural failure, resulting in fragmentation or deformation.", "rule_support_query": "The red hammer head visibly deforms and breaks under the force of the descending metal cylinder, with pieces breaking off and the head flattening.", "rule_support_demo": "The candies, which are brittle, fracture and scatter outward as the hydraulic press descends, demonstrating structural failure under compression.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ (metal hammer vs. candy), but both are brittle or rigid under compression, and both fail in a similar manner under the same type of force application."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_9b35ac1328c468c7de29.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_e4daa645adf4a7ce4378", "query_id": "964b95c72f4e09e561c94d0799be282ea81912846c607f9a3d6992d8005fc4e0", "demo_id": "1ff9234f37fa66aa3f0dbca617102d3c795983f8a209167151d6a4befd3c129f", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/964b95c72f4e09e561c94d0799be282ea81912846c607f9a3d6992d8005fc4e0.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/1ff9234f37fa66aa3f0dbca617102d3c795983f8a209167151d6a4befd3c129f.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_e4daa645adf4a7ce4378", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.6698, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press descends and compresses a coiled metal object placed on a yellow-and-black striped base, causing it to flatten and deform under pressure.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press descends and compresses a green plastic object placed on a yellow-and-black striped base, causing it to deform and eventually burst under pressure.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a hydraulic press applies downward force on an object placed on a stable base, the object deforms or fails under compressive stress, with the nature of deformation depending on the material properties of the object.", "rule_support_query": "The metal object visibly compresses and flattens under the descending press, indicating plastic deformation due to applied force.", "rule_support_demo": "The green plastic object visibly deforms and then bursts under the descending press, indicating failure due to applied force.", "critical_difference": "The materials of the compressed objects differ (metal vs. plastic), leading to different deformation behaviors (plastic compression vs. brittle failure), but the underlying compressive force mechanism is the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_e4daa645adf4a7ce4378.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_94f7236b7998984462d0", "query_id": "b0898f758efd2a6773b90d15a3abecc1b53a4a72039b8a21e3590cea7762a0e1", "demo_id": "354d1754601b926c97c8afc637e39181fa5bde9de673b09760827fba931a95d1", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/b0898f758efd2a6773b90d15a3abecc1b53a4a72039b8a21e3590cea7762a0e1.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/354d1754601b926c97c8afc637e39181fa5bde9de673b09760827fba931a95d1.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_94f7236b7998984462d0", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.5846, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A coconut falls onto a glass table, causing it to shatter explosively with radial cracks spreading outward from the impact point.", "demo_event": "A wine glass is struck by a projectile from the right, causing it to crack and fragment with visible fracture lines propagating from the point of impact.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a brittle material (like glass) is subjected to a sudden, localized impact force, it fractures along paths of least resistance, resulting in crack propagation and fragmentation.", "rule_support_query": "The coconut impacts the glass table, causing immediate radial cracking and fragmentation, with visible crack lines spreading outward from the point of contact.", "rule_support_demo": "The projectile strikes the wine glass, initiating a crack that propagates rapidly across the surface, leading to visible fragmentation and breakage.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in shape and size (coconut vs. wine glass), and the impact surfaces differ (flat table vs. curved glass), but the underlying brittle fracture mechanism is the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_94f7236b7998984462d0.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_2a13039544597b7b5fdf", "query_id": "5d98a7a183e5666cb53237605793d23b46c5453637cadbf4732abfd8906694d0", "demo_id": "fbf3982164a4811302b397ddf1eb35efb50c9c398a70c76570881d627d00f6af", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "gas_particulate_motion", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/5d98a7a183e5666cb53237605793d23b46c5453637cadbf4732abfd8906694d0.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/fbf3982164a4811302b397ddf1eb35efb50c9c398a70c76570881d627d00f6af.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_2a13039544597b7b5fdf", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.4254, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person uses an angle grinder to cut a metal piece clamped in a vise, producing bright sparks.", "demo_event": "A person uses an angle grinder to cut a metal object mounted on a workbench, producing bright sparks.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rotating abrasive disc of an angle grinder is brought into contact with a metal object, high-speed friction generates heat and causes material removal, resulting in sparks and cutting.", "rule_support_query": "The angle grinder's disc is in contact with the metal, producing a consistent stream of sparks, indicating material removal and cutting.", "rule_support_demo": "The angle grinder's disc is in contact with the metal object, producing a consistent stream of sparks, indicating material removal and cutting.", "critical_difference": "The metal object in the QUERY is clamped in a vise, while in the DEMO it is mounted on a workbench; however, this does not affect the core physical mechanism of cutting via abrasive friction."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_2a13039544597b7b5fdf.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_888525dfc42e573f0ff8", "query_id": "b03d20b0f83f2564e2b317f9660f9ed00d5bddb68819344f9a8bb1b7585e7896", "demo_id": "3d9336921ee13fd8bb384165e33195aabf55c6fece8cb8cf03a2ad995ffe9cc5", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "optical_interaction", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/b03d20b0f83f2564e2b317f9660f9ed00d5bddb68819344f9a8bb1b7585e7896.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/3d9336921ee13fd8bb384165e33195aabf55c6fece8cb8cf03a2ad995ffe9cc5.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_888525dfc42e573f0ff8", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.8341, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hand holds an oval opal gemstone, displaying its iridescent play-of-color as light reflects off its polished surface.", "demo_event": "A hand holds an oval opal gemstone, displaying its iridescent play-of-color as light reflects off its polished surface.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When light interacts with the internal structure of a polished opal held under controlled lighting, it produces a dynamic, shifting play-of-color due to diffraction and interference of light waves.", "rule_support_query": "The opal in the QUERY video shows vibrant, shifting colors (green, blue, red, orange) as the hand slightly rotates it, indicating light interaction with its internal structure.", "rule_support_demo": "The opal in the DEMO video similarly displays shifting iridescent colors (green, yellow, red) under light, with slight hand movement altering the visible pattern, consistent with the same optical phenomenon.", "critical_difference": "No critical difference observed; both videos show the same physical phenomenon with identical object type, action, and environmental conditions."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_888525dfc42e573f0ff8.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_0e34332f612c8dd8d886", "query_id": "83ce854bc472b473296178fab715601a50a6afac89798fec9521f06a14698101", "demo_id": "5a02e310829c2987cd95463e8459c1ea251995341a8d62d2d8dc0dede416c5bd", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/83ce854bc472b473296178fab715601a50a6afac89798fec9521f06a14698101.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/5a02e310829c2987cd95463e8459c1ea251995341a8d62d2d8dc0dede416c5bd.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_0e34332f612c8dd8d886", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.5221, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person uses a large bubble wand to create a long, thin, iridescent soap bubble that stretches across a grassy field at dusk, with trees and a body of water in the background.", "demo_event": "A person in a backyard uses a large bubble wand to create a large, elongated, iridescent soap bubble that floats and expands in the air, with a white fence and house visible in the background under a partly cloudy sky.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a large bubble wand is dipped into a soap solution and then lifted and moved through the air, a thin film of soap forms and stretches into a large, iridescent bubble due to surface tension and air flow.", "rule_support_query": "In the QUERY video, the person dips the wand into a solution (implied by the initial state of the wand and the formation of the bubble), lifts it, and moves it through the air, resulting in a large, elongated, iridescent bubble that stretches across the field.", "rule_support_demo": "In the DEMO video, the person dips the wand into a yellow bucket (visible soap solution), lifts it, and moves it through the air, creating a large, elongated, iridescent bubble that expands and floats in the backyard.", "critical_difference": "The environment differs (dusk by a lake vs. daytime in a backyard), but the core physical process of bubble formation via surface tension and air movement is identical and supported by visible evidence in both videos."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_0e34332f612c8dd8d886.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_5bf4d52eac40bebff707", "query_id": "fb704d745faf9d8ebe126488bb605213d7b7ed9bec13c29012fa7c57f5e3e242", "demo_id": "b06e3e9e6de8e8f5f3819dc513ccae1cfe94a06392195cc20897a0075255041e", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/fb704d745faf9d8ebe126488bb605213d7b7ed9bec13c29012fa7c57f5e3e242.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/b06e3e9e6de8e8f5f3819dc513ccae1cfe94a06392195cc20897a0075255041e.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_5bf4d52eac40bebff707", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_surface"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_surface": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.774, "process_sim": 0.854, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 3.2, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A large, furry foot crushes a rock, causing it to shatter into fragments and dust, with debris scattering outward.", "demo_event": "A bat strikes a glass vase on a wooden box, causing it to shatter into pieces and fragments to fly outward.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a force is applied to a brittle object, it fractures and fragments disperse outward due to the release of stored elastic energy and momentum.", "rule_support_query": "The rock shatters upon impact from the foot, with fragments and dust flying outward in a radial pattern.", "rule_support_demo": "The glass vase breaks upon impact from the bat, with shards and pieces scattering outward in a similar radial pattern.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in material (rock vs. glass) and the agent applying force (foot vs. bat), but the fracture and dispersion mechanism is consistent."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_5bf4d52eac40bebff707.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_fa4d272f213fce40d91f", "query_id": "2a20bf87d7ea1ebd18462f7bcaa91649308b32b71a7c9d3f210346ef6060a231", "demo_id": "af17cfe3c21634da919615c12a5f18938e95efad5f800619fa6284be00646d44", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "rigid_motion", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/2a20bf87d7ea1ebd18462f7bcaa91649308b32b71a7c9d3f210346ef6060a231.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/af17cfe3c21634da919615c12a5f18938e95efad5f800619fa6284be00646d44.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_fa4d272f213fce40d91f", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.5401, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A man dribbling a basketball on an outdoor court, moving laterally and forward while maintaining control of the ball.", "demo_event": "A group of children performing a basketball dribbling routine in an indoor gymnasium, moving in coordinated patterns while dribbling.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a person applies downward force to a basketball while moving, the ball rebounds due to elasticity and friction, allowing controlled dribbling motion.", "rule_support_query": "The man repeatedly bounces the ball with his hand, and the ball rebounds off the court surface, maintaining a consistent rhythm and trajectory as he moves.", "rule_support_demo": "Children repeatedly bounce basketballs with their hands, and the balls rebound off the gym floor, allowing them to maintain control and follow coordinated movement patterns.", "critical_difference": "The surface type differs (outdoor asphalt vs. indoor wooden floor), which may affect bounce height and friction, but the core physical mechanism of dribbling remains consistent."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_fa4d272f213fce40d91f.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_b532ccf4ddba91b4274a", "query_id": "f054a2a7e80886f6a6d940e0ffdbeddf14c38350935e180fd4272d4bfc8e4e73", "demo_id": "8fba6ce08e522e65b51efa126fccd74b8abc3243397a7af2f4c7d5414fc0adfd", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/f054a2a7e80886f6a6d940e0ffdbeddf14c38350935e180fd4272d4bfc8e4e73.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/8fba6ce08e522e65b51efa126fccd74b8abc3243397a7af2f4c7d5414fc0adfd.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_b532ccf4ddba91b4274a", "mining_intents": ["hard_motion"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 0.9036, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A knife is used to cut a loaf of bread, slicing through its crust and crumb to separate a piece.", "demo_event": "Gloved hands use a knife to chop dark chocolate into small pieces on a blue cutting board.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "Applying a sharp blade with controlled force to a solid material results in separation along the cut path, producing distinct pieces.", "rule_support_query": "The knife is pressed into the bread with a steady motion, cleanly separating a slice, indicating the blade's cutting action on a solid, cohesive material.", "rule_support_demo": "The knife is repeatedly pressed and moved across the chocolate, breaking it into small, uniform pieces, demonstrating the same cutting mechanism on a solid material.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ in texture and composition (bread vs. chocolate), but the cutting mechanism and outcome are physically consistent."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_b532ccf4ddba91b4274a.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_06ba209d251398567829", "query_id": "e64b64e51249ed2be67ec043a4fef326da26987ac1402f105701628e127c2279", "demo_id": "645752c9b3ee510e3ced20e86d5a876692c7ef87462ad1d8c3c47df5f55fc67e", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "thermal_transfer", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/e64b64e51249ed2be67ec043a4fef326da26987ac1402f105701628e127c2279.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/645752c9b3ee510e3ced20e86d5a876692c7ef87462ad1d8c3c47df5f55fc67e.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_06ba209d251398567829", "mining_intents": ["motion_proxy_different_rule"], "retrieval_features": {"motion_proxy_different_rule": {"motion_is_proxy_only": true, "object_sim": 0.772, "process_sim": 0.765, "role_overlap": 0.75, "rule_score": 1.25, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A flame is applied to a colorful, viscous, swirled mass of material (likely melted wax or polymer) on a metal surface, causing it to bubble and slightly deform.", "demo_event": "A flame from a torch is applied sequentially to the tips of upright, solid colored wax crayons, causing them to melt and drip.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "Applying heat to a material with a low melting point causes it to transition from solid to liquid, resulting in melting, softening, and surface deformation.", "rule_support_query": "The flame causes the colorful mass to bubble and change shape, indicating melting and softening.", "rule_support_demo": "The flame causes the crayon tips to melt and drip, showing a clear phase change from solid to liquid.", "critical_difference": "The query material appears already partially melted and viscous, while the demo material starts as solid crayons; however, both respond to heat with melting and surface deformation."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_06ba209d251398567829.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_ab2a65f484f5637ddce7", "query_id": "86ba814a9417b85b098a91110824b088d55f615d23fa7bdc5e5220192a62fe4f", "demo_id": "d552c48e3d1c4665021f6422cb382b1711e2457042de2e17c3ff274918c00ece", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/86ba814a9417b85b098a91110824b088d55f615d23fa7bdc5e5220192a62fe4f.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/d552c48e3d1c4665021f6422cb382b1711e2457042de2e17c3ff274918c00ece.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_ab2a65f484f5637ddce7", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.7131, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A car tire rolls over a pile of white mushrooms, crushing them into pieces and releasing liquid.", "demo_event": "A car tire rolls over a pile of individually wrapped butter packets, crushing them and causing the contents to ooze out.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid, heavy object (like a car tire) rolls over soft, compressible objects (like mushrooms or butter packets) placed on a hard surface, the objects are crushed due to applied pressure, resulting in deformation, rupture, and release of internal contents.", "rule_support_query": "The mushrooms are visibly crushed and flattened under the tire, with some breaking apart and releasing liquid, indicating internal rupture due to pressure.", "rule_support_demo": "The butter packets are crushed under the tire, with wrappers tearing and butter oozing out, demonstrating rupture and content release due to applied pressure.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in material composition (mushrooms are biological, butter packets are food in plastic), but both are soft and compressible, leading to similar physical responses under the same action."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_ab2a65f484f5637ddce7.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_b56428d4000d3ab94fd6", "query_id": "4889f1140365b337435d13c9a109cbb84a38993d564b0c42bdf926530909fdcf", "demo_id": "5a02e310829c2987cd95463e8459c1ea251995341a8d62d2d8dc0dede416c5bd", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/4889f1140365b337435d13c9a109cbb84a38993d564b0c42bdf926530909fdcf.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/5a02e310829c2987cd95463e8459c1ea251995341a8d62d2d8dc0dede416c5bd.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_b56428d4000d3ab94fd6", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.1506, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A man in a garage creates a large, elongated soap bubble using a circular wand, which stretches and reflects light as it grows.", "demo_event": "A person outdoors in a backyard creates a large, elongated soap bubble using a long wand, which expands and reflects light as it forms.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a wand coated with soap solution is moved through the air, the surface tension of the solution forms a thin film that stretches into a bubble, with size and stability dependent on the motion, solution properties, and environmental conditions.", "rule_support_query": "The man in the garage uses a circular wand to draw a large bubble that elongates and reflects light, indicating surface tension and film formation. The bubble grows as the wand is moved, showing the stretching mechanism.", "rule_support_demo": "The person outdoors uses a long wand to create a large bubble that expands and reflects light, demonstrating the same stretching and film formation due to surface tension. The bubble grows as the wand is moved, consistent with the same physical process.", "critical_difference": "The environments differ (indoor garage vs. outdoor backyard), but the core physical mechanism of bubble formation via surface tension and wand motion remains consistent. No critical condition conflicts are observed."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_b56428d4000d3ab94fd6.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_c16a9ae507a7eda4f1bf", "query_id": "6937d41572945b46af3e3799831b94662c0c69b3f0e17fbc1d2971d52eecd0a7", "demo_id": "6ebc90d35375d1172f9c3a92d5f69b23f4189bd81d5fff3123959f07715c5076", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/6937d41572945b46af3e3799831b94662c0c69b3f0e17fbc1d2971d52eecd0a7.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/6ebc90d35375d1172f9c3a92d5f69b23f4189bd81d5fff3123959f07715c5076.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_c16a9ae507a7eda4f1bf", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_surface"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_surface": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.839, "process_sim": 0.881, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 4.2, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A heavy yellow and black striped hammer crushes a metallic mechanical component placed on a circular platform.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic ram or press crushes a metal object, likely a tool or part, on a wooden surface, causing debris and fragments to scatter.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a heavy, rigid object is forcefully driven downward onto a brittle or structurally weak object, the target object will fracture, deform, or shatter due to applied compressive stress exceeding its material strength.", "rule_support_query": "The metallic component visibly cracks and breaks apart under the impact of the descending hammer, with fragments scattering.", "rule_support_demo": "The metal object breaks into pieces and fragments fly outward as the hydraulic press descends, indicating material failure under compression.", "critical_difference": "The objects being crushed differ in material composition and structure (mechanical component vs. tool/part), and the crushing mechanisms differ slightly (hammer vs. hydraulic press), but both involve high-force compression leading to fracture."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_c16a9ae507a7eda4f1bf.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_33385b38e7ae25490e56", "query_id": "97545b10b540df5c11de2dce0f916af30202647759be351031110dd9e556ea42", "demo_id": "0fd409882cf1c8971568faa710d60f3dfeeacad9290af52317b1ffa64c409bfe", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/97545b10b540df5c11de2dce0f916af30202647759be351031110dd9e556ea42.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/0fd409882cf1c8971568faa710d60f3dfeeacad9290af52317b1ffa64c409bfe.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_33385b38e7ae25490e56", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.0521, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A yellow cylindrical object with green and orange bands is compressed vertically between two metal plates, causing it to deform and buckle into a helical shape.", "demo_event": "An orange is compressed vertically between two metal plates, causing it to flatten and then burst into a flattened disc.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a deformable object is subjected to vertical compressive force between two rigid plates, it undergoes plastic or elastic deformation, leading to a change in shape and volume distribution, depending on material properties.", "rule_support_query": "The yellow cylinder deforms under compression, showing visible buckling and helical folding, indicating material yielding and redistribution under stress.", "rule_support_demo": "The orange deforms under compression, flattening and eventually bursting, showing material failure and fluid redistribution under stress.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ significantly: the cylinder appears to be a solid, possibly viscoelastic or composite material that buckles without rupturing, while the orange is a soft, fluid-filled fruit that ruptures and releases juice upon compression."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_33385b38e7ae25490e56.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_a6a3a39d85c4b5e99a5f", "query_id": "9be722ac5da45f3294766b336d8bb87af492f08308d102aa4faf61d8d25a6d0b", "demo_id": "bb31badc0b232d574cb1ec1b8ee49176ac2e12fe784e7c1536ad9e9524344a5f", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_object_action", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "optical_interaction", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/9be722ac5da45f3294766b336d8bb87af492f08308d102aa4faf61d8d25a6d0b.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/bb31badc0b232d574cb1ec1b8ee49176ac2e12fe784e7c1536ad9e9524344a5f.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_a6a3a39d85c4b5e99a5f", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.9778, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_object_action"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A glass of water is placed in front of a black-and-white zigzag pattern, causing the pattern to appear distorted through the water due to refraction.", "demo_event": "A hand holds a pencil partially submerged in a glass of water, making the pencil appear bent at the water's surface due to refraction.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "different", "motion_similarity": "different", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When light passes from one medium to another with a different optical density (e.g., air to water), it bends, causing objects viewed through the interface to appear displaced or distorted.", "rule_support_query": "The zigzag pattern behind the glass of water appears wavy and distorted when viewed through the water, indicating light bending as it passes through the water-air interface.", "rule_support_demo": "The pencil appears bent at the water's surface, with the submerged part shifted relative to the part above water, demonstrating light refraction at the air-water boundary.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY uses a static pattern viewed through a full glass of water, while the DEMO uses a single object (pencil) partially submerged, but both rely on the same refraction principle."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_a6a3a39d85c4b5e99a5f.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_e7af503ad364d649bc67", "query_id": "4c6484dd6b00b4da45d80d5909bada167cfa15fb830ee592891507329bdf638e", "demo_id": "d552c48e3d1c4665021f6422cb382b1711e2457042de2e17c3ff274918c00ece", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/4c6484dd6b00b4da45d80d5909bada167cfa15fb830ee592891507329bdf638e.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/d552c48e3d1c4665021f6422cb382b1711e2457042de2e17c3ff274918c00ece.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_e7af503ad364d649bc67", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.5574, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A car tire rolls over a row of spray paint cans, causing them to burst and spray paint in various directions.", "demo_event": "A car tire rolls over multiple wrapped candies, crushing them and causing some to burst or deform.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a heavy, rolling object (like a car tire) applies pressure to small, contained objects placed on a rigid surface, the objects deform or burst due to the applied force, releasing their contents if they are pressurized or fragile.", "rule_support_query": "The spray paint cans are crushed by the tire, and their contents are expelled in colorful streams, indicating pressure release from deformation.", "rule_support_demo": "The candies are crushed by the tire, and some burst or deform, showing that the applied force from the tire causes structural failure in the wrappers and contents.", "critical_difference": "The spray paint cans are pressurized containers designed to release contents under force, while the candies are solid or semi-solid items that deform or burst due to mechanical stress; the nature of the released material (liquid paint vs. solid candy) differs, but the causal mechanism of crushing under rolling pressure is the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_e7af503ad364d649bc67.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_2fe356ac0db4f556ca02", "query_id": "549e94ef2bdcc13411678634c1a31b2f78f6a38f733a9ed8dc3996ebd88a6398", "demo_id": "7d4c45ef35057b153359c23f3de533d0ebc1bed0970e8008960389940c96a4b6", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_object_action", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/549e94ef2bdcc13411678634c1a31b2f78f6a38f733a9ed8dc3996ebd88a6398.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/7d4c45ef35057b153359c23f3de533d0ebc1bed0970e8008960389940c96a4b6.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_2fe356ac0db4f556ca02", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.1689, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_object_action"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person holds a large rectangular frame with a soap film stretched across it, creating a giant, iridescent bubble that undulates and changes shape in the wind on a sandy beach.", "demo_event": "A large, elongated, iridescent soap bubble floats and drifts across a wet sandy beach, moving slowly and changing shape as it travels.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "different", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a soap film is stretched across a frame or formed in an open environment, it can form a large, iridescent bubble that floats and deforms under the influence of air currents and gravity, with its shape and stability dependent on surface tension and environmental conditions.", "rule_support_query": "The large soap bubble is formed by stretching a film across a frame held by a person, and it visibly undulates and changes shape in response to wind, demonstrating surface tension and air flow effects.", "rule_support_demo": "The floating bubble moves across the wet sand, changing shape and reflecting light, indicating it is subject to air currents and surface tension, consistent with the behavior of a soap film in an open environment.", "critical_difference": "The query video shows a bubble actively formed and manipulated by a person using a frame, while the demo video shows a bubble already formed and floating freely, but both exhibit the same physical behavior of deformation and iridescence due to surface tension and air flow."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_2fe356ac0db4f556ca02.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_4b73811fef2db478c860", "query_id": "50bdb084a21bd00b36bbcc30dc1d8d077d338ba58c627f4fe7f1744ec099924c", "demo_id": "2a70a33c23a398c7196410b6c5e0fac216f287583bd71d724b2053476aca3e8d", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/50bdb084a21bd00b36bbcc30dc1d8d077d338ba58c627f4fe7f1744ec099924c.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/2a70a33c23a398c7196410b6c5e0fac216f287583bd71d724b2053476aca3e8d.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_4b73811fef2db478c860", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.0788, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press compresses a block of white, fibrous material, causing it to crumble and disintegrate into fine particles and dust.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press crushes a white, brittle material (likely ceramic or plaster) placed on a striped base, causing it to shatter into fragments and dust.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid, heavy object (hydraulic press) applies downward force onto a brittle or compressible material, the material undergoes structural failure, fracturing or crumbling into smaller pieces due to stress exceeding its compressive strength.", "rule_support_query": "The white fibrous material visibly deforms, cracks, and breaks apart under the press, with particles and dust being expelled outward as the press descends.", "rule_support_demo": "The white brittle material shatters into sharp fragments and dust as the press descends, with pieces flying outward and accumulating around the base.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ in composition and texture (fibrous vs. brittle), leading to slightly different fragmentation patterns (crumbling vs. shattering), but both respond to compressive force by breaking down."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_4b73811fef2db478c860.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_3406ec7961ee56bf0c50", "query_id": "9681f8bc37910d4593ea7d2dc4317d57dcd53153978967ad5012b48815fb38e0", "demo_id": "67cc319d7e4ee64d8da328d3ffd630ef775d162e213dcec2d06ba633e001dbed", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/9681f8bc37910d4593ea7d2dc4317d57dcd53153978967ad5012b48815fb38e0.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/67cc319d7e4ee64d8da328d3ffd630ef775d162e213dcec2d06ba633e001dbed.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_3406ec7961ee56bf0c50", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.7754, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A blue insulated water bottle is compressed vertically by a hydraulic press, causing it to deform and eventually burst, releasing liquid.", "demo_event": "A clear glass bottle with a red cap is compressed vertically by a hydraulic press, causing it to shatter into fragments.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a sealed container is subjected to increasing vertical compressive force from a hydraulic press, it will deform and eventually fail, releasing its contents or fracturing, depending on material properties.", "rule_support_query": "The blue bottle deforms under pressure, then bursts and sprays liquid, indicating failure due to compressive stress.", "rule_support_demo": "The glass bottle cracks and shatters under compressive force, with fragments spreading outward, indicating brittle failure under stress.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ: the QUERY bottle is flexible and insulated (likely plastic or metal with rubber), while the DEMO bottle is rigid glass, leading to different failure modes (bursting vs. shattering)."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_3406ec7961ee56bf0c50.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_67ccf4fbd817cc8d8043", "query_id": "e16fb1c1f61120557450b815c41dd7e9093f400cbf43bc3a0da73403dcabd10c", "demo_id": "a064ad09774aaf1ba5aca55d6fea657a67ab811378bd28f180561f249bd41f1e", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fluid_motion", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/e16fb1c1f61120557450b815c41dd7e9093f400cbf43bc3a0da73403dcabd10c.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/a064ad09774aaf1ba5aca55d6fea657a67ab811378bd28f180561f249bd41f1e.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_67ccf4fbd817cc8d8043", "mining_intents": ["positive", "cross_action_hypothesis"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.6461, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person pours blue liquid from one plastic bottle into another connected bottle via a transparent tube, with the receiving bottle lying horizontally and the pouring bottle held upright, allowing liquid to flow through the tube.", "demo_event": "A person pours clear liquid from a soda bottle into a modified plastic bottle setup with a funnel and tube connecting it to another upright bottle, allowing liquid to flow through the tube into the second bottle.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When two containers are connected by a tube and liquid is poured into one, gravity causes the liquid to flow through the tube into the other container until the liquid levels equalize or the pouring stops.", "rule_support_query": "In the QUERY video, blue liquid flows from the upright bottle through the transparent tube into the horizontal bottle, demonstrating gravity-driven flow between connected containers.", "rule_support_demo": "In the DEMO video, clear liquid flows from the soda bottle through a tube into the second upright bottle, showing the same gravity-driven transfer between connected containers.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY video uses a horizontal receiving bottle with a bent tube, while the DEMO uses two upright bottles with a straight tube and funnel; however, the core mechanism of liquid transfer via gravity through a connecting tube remains the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_67ccf4fbd817cc8d8043.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_1a841f63615c8ee01731", "query_id": "470949495cba70aa46190987ec3cffa4ac0a110645e2ff14d9b18096c692f172", "demo_id": "0319949afd438ac6f7801874eae3e5fb8e462e4e8e8411f354b0c3bd0f231c5d", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/470949495cba70aa46190987ec3cffa4ac0a110645e2ff14d9b18096c692f172.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/0319949afd438ac6f7801874eae3e5fb8e462e4e8e8411f354b0c3bd0f231c5d.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_1a841f63615c8ee01731", "mining_intents": ["motion_proxy_different_rule"], "retrieval_features": {"motion_proxy_different_rule": {"motion_is_proxy_only": true, "object_sim": 0.859, "process_sim": 0.761, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 1.533, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person creates large, elongated soap bubbles using a long wand near a coastal cliff at sunrise, with the bubbles expanding and floating away in the wind.", "demo_event": "A person in a lab coat uses a large frame to generate large, iridescent soap bubbles in a grassy suburban yard, which float and drift apart in the air.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a soap solution is drawn across a frame or wand in a windy environment, surface tension and air flow cause the formation of large, thin, iridescent bubbles that expand and drift with the wind.", "rule_support_query": "Large bubbles form from a wand dipped in solution and are carried by wind over the ocean, showing expansion and drift.", "rule_support_demo": "Large bubbles form from a frame dipped in solution and float away in the yard, showing expansion and drift.", "critical_difference": "The environments differ (coastal cliff vs. suburban yard), but the physical mechanism and outcomes are consistent."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_1a841f63615c8ee01731.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_8da85fc7fc89c61b52e5", "query_id": "3a22f5fe24ec23c056329b68851dfc6ce89d5be744e32726b58615e6f9eb7bf4", "demo_id": "dbcff459272edba4435e6c14d2cf805bf9cad60132366b18bd60791069029d91", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/3a22f5fe24ec23c056329b68851dfc6ce89d5be744e32726b58615e6f9eb7bf4.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/dbcff459272edba4435e6c14d2cf805bf9cad60132366b18bd60791069029d91.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_8da85fc7fc89c61b52e5", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_surface", "same_rule_cross_object_action"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_object_action": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.864, "process_sim": 0.833, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 4.0, "same_mechanism_family": true}, "same_rule_cross_surface": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.864, "process_sim": 0.833, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 4.0, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person juggling a soccer ball with their feet on an artificial turf field.", "demo_event": "A person bouncing a basketball on a concrete driveway near a basketball hoop.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a spherical ball is repeatedly struck with a foot or hand on a flat surface, it rebounds due to elastic deformation and gravity, allowing for controlled bouncing or juggling.", "rule_support_query": "The soccer ball consistently rebounds off the person's feet, maintaining a rhythmic motion on artificial turf.", "rule_support_demo": "The basketball bounces predictably on the concrete surface after being struck by the hand, demonstrating elastic rebound.", "critical_difference": "The objects (soccer ball vs. basketball) and surfaces (artificial turf vs. concrete) differ, but the core physical mechanism of elastic rebound and controlled impact remains consistent."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_8da85fc7fc89c61b52e5.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_1ca14bba0c51b124b6fc", "query_id": "0fd409882cf1c8971568faa710d60f3dfeeacad9290af52317b1ffa64c409bfe", "demo_id": "ced0e189f387834be0a4f4a4f2b9bca0fb7825f083fbc0a1ab17123e4a6e6b28", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/0fd409882cf1c8971568faa710d60f3dfeeacad9290af52317b1ffa64c409bfe.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/ced0e189f387834be0a4f4a4f2b9bca0fb7825f083fbc0a1ab17123e4a6e6b28.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_1ca14bba0c51b124b6fc", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.5359, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "An orange is compressed between two metal plates of a hydraulic press, deforming it into a flat disc.", "demo_event": "A green, irregularly shaped object is compressed between two metal plates of a hydraulic press, deforming it into a flatter shape.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a compressible object is placed between two opposing plates of a hydraulic press and subjected to downward force, it deforms plastically or elastically, reducing in height and increasing in lateral dimensions.", "rule_support_query": "The orange, initially spherical, is visibly compressed between the press plates, flattening into a disc while maintaining its volume, indicating plastic deformation under pressure.", "rule_support_demo": "The green object, initially irregular and thick, is compressed between the press plates, flattening and spreading laterally, demonstrating similar deformation under pressure.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in material (orange is biological, green object appears to be foam or plastic), but both exhibit compressibility under the same mechanical action, supporting the same causal rule."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_1ca14bba0c51b124b6fc.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_87b886ad96398ddb97e8", "query_id": "3cf48f2521bc084edee194834170e0933df8c6b625dfc98a379a9ac55e9ac675", "demo_id": "2f484f493644f377f0d1d61a2464edb4be217a9f9334b5d78ffaac92d119900f", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/3cf48f2521bc084edee194834170e0933df8c6b625dfc98a379a9ac55e9ac675.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/2f484f493644f377f0d1d61a2464edb4be217a9f9334b5d78ffaac92d119900f.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_87b886ad96398ddb97e8", "mining_intents": ["hard_motion"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 1.0082, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A yellow water balloon falls onto a mousetrap, triggering it and causing the balloon to burst explosively, splashing water.", "demo_event": "A yellow water balloon is compressed between two metal plates, causing it to burst and eject water and fragments.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "different", "motion_similarity": "different", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a water-filled balloon is subjected to sufficient mechanical force or pressure, it ruptures, releasing its contents explosively.", "rule_support_query": "The balloon bursts upon contact with the triggered mousetrap, resulting in a rapid release of water and fragments, indicating rupture due to mechanical force.", "rule_support_demo": "The balloon bursts under compression from the metal plates, with water and fragments ejected, demonstrating rupture due to applied pressure.", "critical_difference": "The mechanism of force application differs: the QUERY uses a sudden mechanical trigger (mousetrap snap) while the DEMO uses direct compression; however, both result in rupture due to mechanical stress."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_87b886ad96398ddb97e8.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_c69e17a4feca7cd6da96", "query_id": "4cd09bb48d77c42d551bbebce7b102a847bd2eaddb0ecae9b48337548851e913", "demo_id": "dc45b99ec029b18abde2e2d882deb25b305cd45c84aea10f06b5a518ee711c25", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "phase_transition", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/4cd09bb48d77c42d551bbebce7b102a847bd2eaddb0ecae9b48337548851e913.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/dc45b99ec029b18abde2e2d882deb25b305cd45c84aea10f06b5a518ee711c25.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_c69e17a4feca7cd6da96", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_surface", "same_rule_cross_object_action"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_object_action": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.84, "process_sim": 0.852, "role_overlap": 0.6, "rule_score": 4.0, "same_mechanism_family": true}, "same_rule_cross_surface": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.84, "process_sim": 0.852, "role_overlap": 0.6, "rule_score": 4.0, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A blue, crystalline object is heated with a torch, causing it to melt and drip.", "demo_event": "A translucent, star-shaped object melts and drips under heat, likely from a hidden source.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a solid material with a melting point below the applied heat source is exposed to sufficient thermal energy, it undergoes phase transition from solid to liquid, resulting in melting and dripping.", "rule_support_query": "The blue crystalline object visibly softens, melts, and forms droplets that fall under gravity when heated by a torch.", "rule_support_demo": "The star-shaped object visibly melts and drips, indicating phase change due to heat exposure, even without visible heat source.", "critical_difference": "The heat source is visible in the query (torch) but not in the demo, though the outcome suggests similar thermal intervention."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_c69e17a4feca7cd6da96.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_dda5480c7394bf08b921", "query_id": "b94bbfdc4d3236ce5e6779c4b69e37eb906c62b52e428fedd525def2a5491f2d", "demo_id": "e7b5d8ffa7fad5c8d39cb3a287c2788a3a89624671a0d9ac29bc6e76dd7fd6ae", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/b94bbfdc4d3236ce5e6779c4b69e37eb906c62b52e428fedd525def2a5491f2d.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/e7b5d8ffa7fad5c8d39cb3a287c2788a3a89624671a0d9ac29bc6e76dd7fd6ae.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_dda5480c7394bf08b921", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 6.4838, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A silver car collides with a stationary wooden barrier, causing significant front-end deformation and fragmentation of the barrier.", "demo_event": "Two Toyota Corollas (one white, one gray) collide head-on at an angle in a controlled crash test, resulting in front-end deformation and structural damage to both vehicles.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When two rigid bodies (vehicles or barriers) collide with significant kinetic energy, they undergo deformation and structural failure proportional to the force and angle of impact, with energy dissipation through material fracture and crumpling.", "rule_support_query": "The silver car's front end crumples upon impact with the wooden barrier, which breaks apart, indicating energy absorption through deformation and fragmentation.", "rule_support_demo": "Both cars exhibit front-end crumpling and structural damage upon collision, with visible deformation and broken components, consistent with energy absorption during impact.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY involves a car hitting a fixed barrier, while the DEMO involves two moving vehicles colliding; however, the underlying physical response to impact force is consistent in both."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_dda5480c7394bf08b921.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_2d4dedba30ec5efc82e7", "query_id": "0ac293cf12a1b0c9bd1d062a7a210414f40ee4766405f12a6171d63e44d26287", "demo_id": "60762435e374f916117bc6f909c367664480b8805cdfbe7d2f450f2392da9dd1", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/0ac293cf12a1b0c9bd1d062a7a210414f40ee4766405f12a6171d63e44d26287.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/60762435e374f916117bc6f909c367664480b8805cdfbe7d2f450f2392da9dd1.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_2d4dedba30ec5efc82e7", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.9008, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A metallic sphere is compressed between two yellow and black striped cylindrical surfaces as a top cylinder descends, causing the sphere to deform under pressure.", "demo_event": "A plastic toy structure enclosed in a mesh net is crushed by a descending cylindrical press, causing the toy to break and deform under pressure.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a compressive force is applied by a descending cylindrical press to an object placed between two surfaces, the object deforms or breaks due to the applied pressure.", "rule_support_query": "The metallic sphere visibly deforms as the top cylinder descends, indicating compression and plastic deformation under pressure.", "rule_support_demo": "The plastic toy structure breaks and deforms as the press descends, showing material failure under compressive force.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in material (metallic sphere vs. plastic toy), leading to different deformation behaviors (plastic deformation vs. brittle fracture), but the underlying compressive force mechanism is the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_2d4dedba30ec5efc82e7.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_b36fe857514da97b43d5", "query_id": "38071a348fd4e26b1e488a3acf9e04216a781c27dbfb5a8866ddfad201b0477e", "demo_id": "cd3776d15d3d311d4ff0d6765f7b7972ef4246e25eace7337b89dba206fd118c", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "relation_reconfiguration", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/38071a348fd4e26b1e488a3acf9e04216a781c27dbfb5a8866ddfad201b0477e.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/cd3776d15d3d311d4ff0d6765f7b7972ef4246e25eace7337b89dba206fd118c.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_b36fe857514da97b43d5", "mining_intents": ["positive", "cross_action_hypothesis"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.0045, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "Metal rods with magnetic balls at ends are scattered on a white surface, and hands gather and manipulate them, causing magnetic attraction and alignment.", "demo_event": "Metal balls are arranged in a cluster and a line on a white surface, and a hand adds more balls, causing them to magnetically attract and align into a chain.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When magnetic balls or magnetically connected rods are brought into proximity, they attract and align due to magnetic forces, forming chains or clusters.", "rule_support_query": "Metal rods with magnetic balls at ends are seen attracting each other and aligning when hands move them closer, forming connected structures.", "rule_support_demo": "Metal balls are shown attracting and aligning into a chain when a hand places additional balls near the existing cluster or line.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY uses rods with balls at ends, while the DEMO uses standalone balls; however, both exhibit magnetic attraction and alignment, supporting the same physical rule."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_b36fe857514da97b43d5.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_61ab0b341c5dda69b0b8", "query_id": "cb79c9da3e13102b6573dc425fdd8c40f77f456565f2b1b16a4512fbfb2d2136", "demo_id": "83eb62a523eab85851fec6731108c8f9bbb6564b7188faf889a207bde035247e", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "rigid_motion", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/cb79c9da3e13102b6573dc425fdd8c40f77f456565f2b1b16a4512fbfb2d2136.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/83eb62a523eab85851fec6731108c8f9bbb6564b7188faf889a207bde035247e.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_61ab0b341c5dda69b0b8", "mining_intents": ["positive", "cross_action_hypothesis"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.9851, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "An astronaut in microgravity pushes off from a surface and floats away, demonstrating Newton's third law of motion (action-reaction) in a zero-gravity environment.", "demo_event": "A person on a sandy surface throws a ball, causing them to recoil slightly backward due to the reaction force, illustrating Newton's third law in a terrestrial environment with gravity and friction.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "different", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a force is applied to an object, an equal and opposite force is exerted by the object on the source of the force, resulting in motion or recoil of the source in the opposite direction.", "rule_support_query": "The astronaut pushes off a surface with his hands, and his body moves in the opposite direction, floating away in microgravity, with no other forces (like friction or gravity) to counteract the motion. The 'FORCE PAIR' graphic visually emphasizes the action-reaction pair.", "rule_support_demo": "The person throws a ball forward, and their body recoils backward slightly, demonstrating the reaction force. The sandy ground and gravity are present, but the recoil is still observable, confirming the action-reaction principle.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY occurs in microgravity with negligible friction, allowing continuous motion after the push, while the DEMO occurs on Earth with gravity and friction, limiting the recoil motion and causing the person to remain grounded."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_61ab0b341c5dda69b0b8.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_7ad8f22606e6ba730343", "query_id": "2f484f493644f377f0d1d61a2464edb4be217a9f9334b5d78ffaac92d119900f", "demo_id": "2a70a33c23a398c7196410b6c5e0fac216f287583bd71d724b2053476aca3e8d", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/2f484f493644f377f0d1d61a2464edb4be217a9f9334b5d78ffaac92d119900f.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/2a70a33c23a398c7196410b6c5e0fac216f287583bd71d724b2053476aca3e8d.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_7ad8f22606e6ba730343", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_surface"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_surface": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.817, "process_sim": 0.848, "role_overlap": 0.5, "rule_score": 3.76, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A bright yellow plastic object is crushed by a descending metal press, shattering into fragments and pieces that fly outward.", "demo_event": "A pile of white, brittle material (possibly ceramic or foam) is crushed by a descending metal press, breaking into small fragments and producing dust or fine particles.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid, heavy object (press) descends onto a brittle or fragile material under confinement, the material fractures and fragments due to compressive stress exceeding its strength, with fragments and particles dispersing outward.", "rule_support_query": "The yellow object shatters and fragments fly outward as the press descends, indicating brittle fracture under compression.", "rule_support_demo": "The white material breaks into pieces and dust as the press descends, showing similar brittle fracture and particle dispersion.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ in color and likely composition (plastic vs. ceramic/foam), but both exhibit brittle fracture under compression."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_7ad8f22606e6ba730343.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_ed719f9b1401420a7849", "query_id": "17efd25586576d56f5c93c4ef09f11840ffdb3222f8d070544798203a4509c2d", "demo_id": "bb31badc0b232d574cb1ec1b8ee49176ac2e12fe784e7c1536ad9e9524344a5f", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_object_action", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "optical_interaction", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/17efd25586576d56f5c93c4ef09f11840ffdb3222f8d070544798203a4509c2d.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/bb31badc0b232d574cb1ec1b8ee49176ac2e12fe784e7c1536ad9e9524344a5f.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_ed719f9b1401420a7849", "mining_intents": ["positive", "cross_action_hypothesis"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.9828, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_object_action"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A child's face appears distorted when viewed through a glass of water, with the lower part of the face appearing magnified and compressed due to refraction.", "demo_event": "A hand holds a pencil partially submerged in a glass of water, causing the pencil to appear bent or broken at the water surface due to refraction.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "different", "motion_similarity": "different", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When light passes from one medium to another with a different refractive index (e.g., air to water), it bends, causing objects viewed through the interface to appear displaced, magnified, or distorted.", "rule_support_query": "The child's face appears distorted through the glass of water, with the lower part magnified and compressed, indicating refraction at the water-air interface.", "rule_support_demo": "The pencil appears bent at the water surface, demonstrating refraction as light bends when transitioning between air and water.", "critical_difference": "The query involves a face viewed through a cylindrical glass, causing both magnification and distortion, while the demo uses a straight pencil in a glass, showing a bending effect. However, both rely on the same refraction principle."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_ed719f9b1401420a7849.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_aa6da3717fc937fdefc3", "query_id": "aa00f27cc7215c18c15b32b4fe8494024d311c7b83b55efc63b17e011a716fc9", "demo_id": "9d939dcea005b5b38e56b0c3dd9a21e405047eae61a8877d5e816178af70025e", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/aa00f27cc7215c18c15b32b4fe8494024d311c7b83b55efc63b17e011a716fc9.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/9d939dcea005b5b38e56b0c3dd9a21e405047eae61a8877d5e816178af70025e.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_aa6da3717fc937fdefc3", "mining_intents": ["same_object_different_rule"], "retrieval_features": {"same_object_different_rule": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.867, "process_sim": 0.733, "role_overlap": 0.5, "rule_score": 1.207, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A large red and yellow axe-like object, mounted on a mechanical arm, swings down and strikes a pumpkin placed on a metal platform, causing it to shatter and scatter debris.", "demo_event": "A large hammer with a yellow handle and metallic head, mounted on a mechanical arm, strikes a metal object on the ground, causing a burst of dust and debris.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "A heavy, rigid object swung with force from a mechanical arm impacts a target object on a surface, causing rapid deformation, fragmentation, and ejection of debris due to kinetic energy transfer.", "rule_support_query": "The axe swings down and strikes the pumpkin, which shatters and scatters pieces and dust upon impact.", "rule_support_demo": "The hammer swings down and strikes a metal object, resulting in a burst of dust and debris, indicating forceful impact.", "critical_difference": "The target objects differ (pumpkin vs. metal object), leading to different material responses (fragmentation vs. deformation/dust), but the underlying impact mechanism remains the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_aa6da3717fc937fdefc3.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_2a9dde66cd7e7d1a50db", "query_id": "3e668e13448f0489936b56fb24fe256067039cff970cd2fdb77070fd60ea6813", "demo_id": "363d1fd5454d9513fde9e32fc856876e0fcafc5f83227ce796f8c8cbcfaa93e7", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/3e668e13448f0489936b56fb24fe256067039cff970cd2fdb77070fd60ea6813.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/363d1fd5454d9513fde9e32fc856876e0fcafc5f83227ce796f8c8cbcfaa93e7.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_2a9dde66cd7e7d1a50db", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.1668, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A car tire rolls over three blocks of dry instant noodles, crushing them into fragments on a rough asphalt surface.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press descends vertically onto a cylindrical object wrapped in black-and-yellow tape, crushing it and surrounding rock fragments into powder and debris.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid object applies sufficient compressive force to a brittle material, the material fractures and deforms into smaller pieces.", "rule_support_query": "The car tire, as it rolls over the noodles, applies compressive force, causing the brittle noodles to shatter and spread out into fragments, demonstrating brittle fracture under pressure.", "rule_support_demo": "The hydraulic press applies downward compressive force to a brittle object, causing it to fracture and crumble into powder and debris, consistent with brittle material failure under pressure.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY involves a rolling motion and a tire on an outdoor asphalt surface, while the DEMO uses a static, vertical press in a controlled indoor environment; however, the core physical mechanism of brittle fracture under compressive force remains consistent."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_2a9dde66cd7e7d1a50db.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_2fc9b4f2492763760a00", "query_id": "fa86f8cffb1b464bb5afe274cfa526a87d40333e1c0dc6ccf9bb9046ff41c3c0", "demo_id": "999faf30bd6a0eb9cd37a4065a6334df54be6f023de44f366cecddd4ee97789b", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/fa86f8cffb1b464bb5afe274cfa526a87d40333e1c0dc6ccf9bb9046ff41c3c0.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/999faf30bd6a0eb9cd37a4065a6334df54be6f023de44f366cecddd4ee97789b.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_2fc9b4f2492763760a00", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.3827, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press compresses a pile of colorful, ring-shaped candies, causing them to fracture and spread outward.", "demo_event": "A large metal hammer strikes the head of a red-handled hammer resting on a striped base, causing visible deformation and cracking of the red head.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid object applies a concentrated force to a brittle or deformable material, the material undergoes fracture or plastic deformation at the point of contact.", "rule_support_query": "The hydraulic press applies downward force to the candies, which are brittle and break apart under pressure, with fragments spreading radially.", "rule_support_demo": "The metal hammer applies a concentrated impact force to the red hammer head, which cracks and deforms under the load, indicating brittle failure.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY involves continuous compression from a hydraulic press, while the DEMO involves a single impact from a falling hammer; however, both result in material failure due to applied force exceeding material strength."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_2fc9b4f2492763760a00.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_03d633a4f9cb2dc21a1e", "query_id": "769f1a85510cf1e72e67ab92ac31059a86ffa8e90b769ef743e0cea8dce3c2d1", "demo_id": "22c7f7e65e01877f3acb63187006f15a70fe33ba76d9f1853e96840aec128da1", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/769f1a85510cf1e72e67ab92ac31059a86ffa8e90b769ef743e0cea8dce3c2d1.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/22c7f7e65e01877f3acb63187006f15a70fe33ba76d9f1853e96840aec128da1.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_03d633a4f9cb2dc21a1e", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.0776, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A red toy car is crushed under the tire of a real vehicle, deforming and breaking as the tire rolls over it.", "demo_event": "A colorful lollipop is compressed and crushed by a descending hydraulic press, causing it to deform and break apart.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid or semi-rigid object is subjected to a large compressive force from a descending or rolling mass, it undergoes deformation and fracture due to material failure under stress.", "rule_support_query": "The toy car deforms and breaks as the tire rolls over it, showing visible cracking and fragmentation under applied pressure.", "rule_support_demo": "The lollipop deforms and breaks into pieces as the press descends, with visible material failure and fragmentation under compressive force.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY involves a rolling contact force from a tire, while the DEMO uses a static, downward-pressing force from a hydraulic press; however, both result in material failure under compression."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_03d633a4f9cb2dc21a1e.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_439a941e10ca9665a341", "query_id": "238ec36b767e50e045af79751d309d478ab424f80002f0455d4b1b665cf071bf", "demo_id": "9a73a6db3f4bb77ba78f8c35c8cceee6d8527cdf6d78c215017fba87282aa9f7", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fluid_motion", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/238ec36b767e50e045af79751d309d478ab424f80002f0455d4b1b665cf071bf.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/9a73a6db3f4bb77ba78f8c35c8cceee6d8527cdf6d78c215017fba87282aa9f7.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_439a941e10ca9665a341", "mining_intents": ["positive", "cross_action_hypothesis"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.2256, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A yellow liquid is poured from a metal strainer into a glass mug, creating foam on top, with sugarcane visible in the background.", "demo_event": "A creamy white liquid is poured through a fine mesh strainer into a bowl, with vanilla beans visible in the strainer, likely to remove solids.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "Pouring a liquid through a strainer to separate solids from the liquid, resulting in a filtered liquid with foam or bubbles on top.", "rule_support_query": "The yellow liquid is poured through a metal strainer into a glass mug, and foam forms on top, indicating filtration and aeration.", "rule_support_demo": "The creamy white liquid is poured through a fine mesh strainer into a bowl, with visible solids (vanilla beans) retained in the strainer, showing filtration.", "critical_difference": "The query involves a yellow liquid with sugarcane context, possibly juice, while the demo involves a creamy white liquid with vanilla beans, likely a dessert base; however, the core physical process of straining liquid to remove solids is identical."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_439a941e10ca9665a341.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_e29bd491b6f1e209fc8d", "query_id": "363d1fd5454d9513fde9e32fc856876e0fcafc5f83227ce796f8c8cbcfaa93e7", "demo_id": "f51374c1775c3a48e6d826d8d78ed725e2216b1448b39f162593779fcc4006b1", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/363d1fd5454d9513fde9e32fc856876e0fcafc5f83227ce796f8c8cbcfaa93e7.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/f51374c1775c3a48e6d826d8d78ed725e2216b1448b39f162593779fcc4006b1.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_e29bd491b6f1e209fc8d", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_surface"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_surface": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.882, "process_sim": 0.943, "role_overlap": 0.8, "rule_score": 4.2, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A cylindrical metal press descends onto a black-and-yellow striped object, crushing it and causing fragments and white powder to scatter outward.", "demo_event": "A conical metal press descends onto a small, dark, irregular object, fracturing it into pieces and ejecting debris and fine particles.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid, heavy object is pressed downward onto a brittle or fragile material under confinement, the material fractures and fragments are ejected outward due to compressive stress exceeding material strength.", "rule_support_query": "The metal press crushes the striped object, causing visible fragmentation and ejection of debris and powder, indicating brittle failure under compression.", "rule_support_demo": "The conical press fractures the small object, with pieces and particles being expelled outward, demonstrating brittle failure under compressive force.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in shape, size, and surface appearance, but both exhibit brittle fracture under compression, supporting the same physical rule."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_e29bd491b6f1e209fc8d.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_674535eda0ec8a4c8a4e", "query_id": "67eb28b8a184e9be6c596a4491307511cb95cb90536a4f35bb6e05d02c91b395", "demo_id": "16ff02e2cd303840c396a45b323d5c9824a8324c7d97301182d99847bc2537e2", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/67eb28b8a184e9be6c596a4491307511cb95cb90536a4f35bb6e05d02c91b395.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/16ff02e2cd303840c396a45b323d5c9824a8324c7d97301182d99847bc2537e2.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_674535eda0ec8a4c8a4e", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.5325, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person slices a loaf of bread into even pieces using a knife on a wooden cutting board.", "demo_event": "A knife cuts through multiple heart-shaped sponges, slicing them into thin, uniform strips on a white surface.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "Applying a steady, downward cutting force with a knife through a solid, cohesive object results in clean, linear separation along the cut path, producing distinct pieces.", "rule_support_query": "The knife moves steadily through the bread, creating clean, straight cuts that separate the loaf into uniform slices without crumbling or tearing excessively, indicating cohesive material response to the cutting force.", "rule_support_demo": "The knife cuts through the sponges with consistent motion, producing clean, parallel slices, demonstrating the same cutting mechanism on a different material with similar structural cohesion.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ (bread vs. sponge), but both are solid, cohesive, and respond to the cutting force by separating cleanly along the blade's path, supporting the same physical rule."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_674535eda0ec8a4c8a4e.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_bcd42db99b5c4b00ef75", "query_id": "5d8163160226962de94ce0aae3bcddb38b03f77b2ccc954f40f7ce6f45a180be", "demo_id": "656320f9a48c2342c85c4b3e6f6ae6db156af1420e70b8c221927b727e5a8d49", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/5d8163160226962de94ce0aae3bcddb38b03f77b2ccc954f40f7ce6f45a180be.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/656320f9a48c2342c85c4b3e6f6ae6db156af1420e70b8c221927b727e5a8d49.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_bcd42db99b5c4b00ef75", "mining_intents": ["hard_motion"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 1.0172, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press compresses a metallic automotive part, causing it to deform and fracture under pressure.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press compresses a stack of blue and white foam or plastic blocks, causing them to crush and compact.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid, downward-acting force is applied via a hydraulic press to a material placed on a fixed base, the material undergoes compression, leading to deformation, fracture, or compaction depending on its material properties.", "rule_support_query": "The metallic part visibly deforms, cracks, and breaks apart as the press descends, with fragments being displaced outward, indicating material failure under compressive stress.", "rule_support_demo": "The foam/plastic blocks visibly compress and flatten under the press, with material being squeezed and displaced, indicating compaction under compressive stress.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ significantly: the QUERY involves a rigid, brittle metal part that fractures, while the DEMO involves a softer, compressible material that compacts without fracturing. However, the underlying physical mechanism of compression under a hydraulic press is the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_bcd42db99b5c4b00ef75.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_2f0a75baa6e96c065212", "query_id": "cffde92bb69c2c57d17d9a31eeee6c79ea81d71f583d865041e1d0f42b9094fc", "demo_id": "3ad7db8b12c61dbf73ff73893e02e34501eb2a9f2749ee4da5ffd94f14f20b51", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/cffde92bb69c2c57d17d9a31eeee6c79ea81d71f583d865041e1d0f42b9094fc.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/3ad7db8b12c61dbf73ff73893e02e34501eb2a9f2749ee4da5ffd94f14f20b51.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_2f0a75baa6e96c065212", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.3129, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "Large, iridescent soap bubbles are formed and float above a beach, created by people using bubble wands near the shoreline.", "demo_event": "A large, transparent soap film is stretched between two curved rods, forming a thin, shimmering bubble structure under bright sunlight.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a soapy solution is stretched across a frame or wand and lifted through the air, surface tension and air flow cause a thin film to form and expand into a bubble or bubble structure, which reflects light to produce iridescent colors.", "rule_support_query": "The video shows large, colorful bubbles forming above the beach, with people using wands to create them, indicating the use of soapy solution and motion to stretch the film into bubbles.", "rule_support_demo": "The video shows a transparent soap film being stretched between two rods, with sunlight reflecting off the surface, demonstrating the formation of a thin film due to surface tension and the stretching action.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY shows multiple large bubbles forming in an open beach environment with wind and people, while the DEMO shows a single, controlled bubble structure under direct sunlight with no wind or multiple participants, but the core physical mechanism remains the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_2f0a75baa6e96c065212.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_6a8f864e90e3a8d18c88", "query_id": "e7b5d8ffa7fad5c8d39cb3a287c2788a3a89624671a0d9ac29bc6e76dd7fd6ae", "demo_id": "b94bbfdc4d3236ce5e6779c4b69e37eb906c62b52e428fedd525def2a5491f2d", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/e7b5d8ffa7fad5c8d39cb3a287c2788a3a89624671a0d9ac29bc6e76dd7fd6ae.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/b94bbfdc4d3236ce5e6779c4b69e37eb906c62b52e428fedd525def2a5491f2d.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_6a8f864e90e3a8d18c88", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 6.4838, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "Two Toyota Corollas collide head-on in a controlled crash test, resulting in significant front-end deformation and fragmentation of both vehicles.", "demo_event": "A silver sedan collides with a stationary barrier, causing severe front-end deformation and structural failure of the vehicle.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a vehicle collides with a rigid object or another vehicle at high speed, the kinetic energy is absorbed through structural deformation, leading to damage to the front end and potential fragmentation of components.", "rule_support_query": "The white and gray Corollas collide head-on, causing visible crumpling, broken glass, and debris scattering, indicating energy absorption through deformation.", "rule_support_demo": "The silver sedan impacts a rigid barrier, resulting in front-end collapse, broken parts, and debris, demonstrating energy absorption via structural deformation.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY involves a two-vehicle collision, while the DEMO involves a single vehicle hitting a barrier; however, the underlying physical response to high-speed impact is consistent."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_6a8f864e90e3a8d18c88.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_17a805644de440b2872b", "query_id": "06a482e0a1251bb736dda57f27a914b986dd2cf5e4ace9a310c753eceebe5452", "demo_id": "37ae5fcc80ba2618ca09e8ca7267ddd53b1e29a110fc9614a926fbb228f2bc93", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/06a482e0a1251bb736dda57f27a914b986dd2cf5e4ace9a310c753eceebe5452.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/37ae5fcc80ba2618ca09e8ca7267ddd53b1e29a110fc9614a926fbb228f2bc93.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_17a805644de440b2872b", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_object_action"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_object_action": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.823, "process_sim": 0.869, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 4.0, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A woman squeezes a pink water balloon held by a man, causing it to deform and eventually burst, releasing water.", "demo_event": "A man sits with multiple balloons on his head and body; another person pops a purple balloon near his head, causing it to burst and release water, while other balloons on him also burst sequentially.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a water-filled balloon is subjected to sufficient external pressure or puncture, it ruptures, releasing its contents due to the elastic limit of the balloon material being exceeded.", "rule_support_query": "The woman applies pressure to the pink water balloon, which deforms and then bursts, releasing water — consistent with the balloon's material failing under stress.", "rule_support_demo": "The purple balloon is punctured or pressed, causing it to burst and release water, and other balloons on the man also burst under similar stress — demonstrating the same rupture mechanism.", "critical_difference": "The DEMO involves multiple balloons and a more complex setup (balloons on head and body), while the QUERY focuses on a single balloon being manually squeezed. However, the core physical mechanism of rupture under pressure remains the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_17a805644de440b2872b.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_ef41ef58fe18324938c4", "query_id": "f51374c1775c3a48e6d826d8d78ed725e2216b1448b39f162593779fcc4006b1", "demo_id": "50bdb084a21bd00b36bbcc30dc1d8d077d338ba58c627f4fe7f1744ec099924c", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/f51374c1775c3a48e6d826d8d78ed725e2216b1448b39f162593779fcc4006b1.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/50bdb084a21bd00b36bbcc30dc1d8d077d338ba58c627f4fe7f1744ec099924c.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_ef41ef58fe18324938c4", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.3215, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A small, dark, irregularly shaped object is crushed between a conical metal press and a flat metal base, breaking into fragments and releasing fine particles.", "demo_event": "A cylindrical block of a fibrous, light-colored material is compressed by a descending metal piston, causing it to deform, fracture, and disintegrate into fibrous debris.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a compressive force is applied to a brittle or friable material between two rigid surfaces, the material will fracture and disintegrate into smaller pieces and particles.", "rule_support_query": "The object breaks apart into multiple fragments and releases fine dust as the conical press descends, indicating brittle fracture under compression.", "rule_support_demo": "The fibrous block visibly cracks, deforms, and breaks into smaller pieces and fibers as the metal piston presses down, demonstrating material failure under compression.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ in composition and structure (dark, dense, possibly metallic vs. light, fibrous, possibly insulation), but both exhibit brittle or friable behavior under compression."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_ef41ef58fe18324938c4.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_ba030d7973ef82e598fe", "query_id": "d552c48e3d1c4665021f6422cb382b1711e2457042de2e17c3ff274918c00ece", "demo_id": "4c6484dd6b00b4da45d80d5909bada167cfa15fb830ee592891507329bdf638e", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/d552c48e3d1c4665021f6422cb382b1711e2457042de2e17c3ff274918c00ece.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/4c6484dd6b00b4da45d80d5909bada167cfa15fb830ee592891507329bdf638e.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_ba030d7973ef82e598fe", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.5574, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A car tire rolls over multiple individually wrapped candies on a paved surface, crushing them.", "demo_event": "A car tire rolls over a row of spray paint cans lying on a paved surface, causing them to spray paint as they are crushed.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a heavy object (car tire) rolls over small, fragile objects placed on a flat surface, the objects are crushed due to applied pressure and deformation from the tire's weight and motion.", "rule_support_query": "The tire rolls over the candies, which are crushed and flattened, indicating deformation under pressure from the tire's weight and motion.", "rule_support_demo": "The tire rolls over spray paint cans, which burst and spray paint as they are crushed, showing deformation and rupture under the same pressure and motion.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in material and response: candies deform and break, while spray cans rupture and release contents, but both are crushed by the tire's weight and motion."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_ba030d7973ef82e598fe.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_af6ce5f14cc460a9540c", "query_id": "d21915573b6936d08807105f74f8bb2ab3aa3346d0be672bf5af9af72d97f0ef", "demo_id": "d8d501b11e15b8bdba40cb8158471bebdceacc0b761f5373da42200535f64b5a", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "rigid_motion", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/d21915573b6936d08807105f74f8bb2ab3aa3346d0be672bf5af9af72d97f0ef.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/d8d501b11e15b8bdba40cb8158471bebdceacc0b761f5373da42200535f64b5a.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_af6ce5f14cc460a9540c", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.5085, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A blue ball is placed at the right end of a wooden zigzag track and rolls down through the grooves, eventually falling into a bowl at the left end.", "demo_event": "Multiple steel balls are loaded onto a white mechanical device with multiple parallel tracks; they roll down the tracks and are guided through a series of loops and curves, eventually being collected at the bottom.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a ball is placed at the high end of a sloped, curved track, gravity causes it to roll down the track, following the path of least resistance, and exit at the low end.", "rule_support_query": "The blue ball is released at the right end of the wooden track and rolls down the zigzag groove, following the path until it falls into the bowl on the left.", "rule_support_demo": "Steel balls are released at the top of the white mechanical track and roll down through multiple curved and looped paths, guided by gravity, and collected at the bottom.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY uses a single wooden track with a single ball, while the DEMO uses a multi-track mechanical device with multiple balls, but both rely on gravity-driven rolling motion along a curved path."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_af6ce5f14cc460a9540c.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_8d94c99705e041337650", "query_id": "9099b77a820def82a2221e5c34fd163bc31c58b49b47e746ee86cae71ca3d0be", "demo_id": "08e96c00970f8df8c072111fcf9530aa9453dee06c5ed6646f933139ebea893b", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "contact_loading", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/9099b77a820def82a2221e5c34fd163bc31c58b49b47e746ee86cae71ca3d0be.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/08e96c00970f8df8c072111fcf9530aa9453dee06c5ed6646f933139ebea893b.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_8d94c99705e041337650", "mining_intents": ["same_object_different_rule"], "retrieval_features": {"same_object_different_rule": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.883, "process_sim": 0.799, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 2.6, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hand places a third black magnetic ball next to two already touching balls, causing them to align into a straight line due to magnetic attraction.", "demo_event": "A hand places a column of silver magnetic balls next to a row of similar columns, causing them to align into a straight line due to magnetic attraction.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When magnetic spheres are brought into proximity, they attract and align into a linear configuration due to magnetic forces.", "rule_support_query": "The third black ball rolls and aligns with the two existing balls, forming a straight line, indicating magnetic attraction.", "rule_support_demo": "The columns of silver magnetic balls are placed in a row and align linearly, showing magnetic attraction between them.", "critical_difference": "none"}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_8d94c99705e041337650.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_f8dd1654d0f055d28226", "query_id": "401a5cd258cb0c80b6f94b3a41091a92d1d517a84f03a21ca65051d384dc1384", "demo_id": "83ce854bc472b473296178fab715601a50a6afac89798fec9521f06a14698101", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/401a5cd258cb0c80b6f94b3a41091a92d1d517a84f03a21ca65051d384dc1384.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/83ce854bc472b473296178fab715601a50a6afac89798fec9521f06a14698101.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_f8dd1654d0f055d28226", "mining_intents": ["positive", "cross_action_hypothesis"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.7755, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person on a beach creates a large, iridescent soap bubble using a long frame, with the sun reflecting off the bubble's surface.", "demo_event": "A person in a park creates a large, iridescent soap bubble using a long frame, with the sunset providing a colorful backdrop.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a person moves a large frame coated with soapy solution through the air, a thin film of soap forms across the frame, which expands into a large bubble due to air resistance and surface tension, producing iridescent colors from light interference.", "rule_support_query": "In the QUERY video, the person holds a long frame and moves it through the air, forming a large, expanding, iridescent bubble that reflects sunlight, indicating the soap film is intact and expanding due to air movement.", "rule_support_demo": "In the DEMO video, the person similarly moves a long frame through the air, forming a large, expanding, iridescent bubble that reflects the sunset, showing the same soap film formation and expansion mechanism.", "critical_difference": "The surface (beach vs. park) and lighting conditions (sunlight vs. sunset) differ, but these do not affect the core physical mechanism of bubble formation via frame movement and surface tension."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_f8dd1654d0f055d28226.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_126a2b9f2e328c962716", "query_id": "73351df6d4f0b49778264c6e6c7b4b8289d515054db22ff79ea31efb87638ec3", "demo_id": "eb066ee7214945f937d670b7dee8562745bf0326744fd1557653d50a91b282cf", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/73351df6d4f0b49778264c6e6c7b4b8289d515054db22ff79ea31efb87638ec3.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/eb066ee7214945f937d670b7dee8562745bf0326744fd1557653d50a91b282cf.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_126a2b9f2e328c962716", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 6.6163, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A high-pressure jet cuts through a green material placed on a wooden block, causing it to shatter and fly apart with sparks.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press crushes a hammer placed on a stack of black discs, causing the hammer to break apart and fragments to fly outward with sparks.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a high-force, localized action is applied to a brittle or rigid object, it fractures or shatters, often producing fragments and sparks due to rapid energy release.", "rule_support_query": "The jet applies focused force to the green material, which fractures violently with visible sparks and flying pieces, indicating rapid energy release and material failure.", "rule_support_demo": "The hydraulic press applies downward force to the hammer, which breaks apart with visible sparks and flying fragments, demonstrating similar material failure under high force.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY uses a jet-based cutting mechanism, while the DEMO uses a mechanical press; however, both result in brittle fracture under high localized force, supporting the same causal rule."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_126a2b9f2e328c962716.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_9f69ee2ce11df0455291", "query_id": "b06e3e9e6de8e8f5f3819dc513ccae1cfe94a06392195cc20897a0075255041e", "demo_id": "fffd648abd540add4b9503b72619a4b9943a7e88a70637ddc21f9b3498fae339", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/b06e3e9e6de8e8f5f3819dc513ccae1cfe94a06392195cc20897a0075255041e.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/fffd648abd540add4b9503b72619a4b9943a7e88a70637ddc21f9b3498fae339.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_9f69ee2ce11df0455291", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.1652, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A glass object is struck by a bat, causing it to shatter into fragments and debris.", "demo_event": "A series of glass panels are shattered by an impact, resulting in fragmentation and debris dispersion.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a brittle material like glass is subjected to a sudden, high-impact force, it fractures and shatters into multiple pieces, with fragments dispersing outward from the point of impact.", "rule_support_query": "The glass object on the wooden box shatters upon being struck by a bat, with fragments flying outward and debris scattering across the surface.", "rule_support_demo": "The glass panels are shown breaking upon impact, with visible cracks spreading and fragments flying outward, consistent with brittle fracture under impact.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY involves a single glass object struck by a bat in an outdoor setting, while the DEMO features multiple glass panels in a controlled indoor environment, but both exhibit the same fundamental fracture mechanism under impact."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_9f69ee2ce11df0455291.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_be5029da718edc9a0c49", "query_id": "ff94aeca4b0514010c10cb631b1182f6efb4ea53ffc2f1a2f320866acd020cad", "demo_id": "4913b8877cf5a1cbea8e19159cbac59bb8a77b9fd67d7a8ecb02241d29fc644c", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fluid_motion", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/ff94aeca4b0514010c10cb631b1182f6efb4ea53ffc2f1a2f320866acd020cad.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/4913b8877cf5a1cbea8e19159cbac59bb8a77b9fd67d7a8ecb02241d29fc644c.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_be5029da718edc9a0c49", "mining_intents": ["positive", "cross_action_hypothesis"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.7728, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A woman uses a large bubble wand to create multiple large, interconnected soap bubbles in an outdoor setting with onlookers.", "demo_event": "A person in a grassy field creates a long, flowing, ribbon-like soap bubble structure that extends horizontally across the field, with smaller bubbles forming at the end.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a soap solution is drawn through a frame or wand and exposed to air, surface tension and airflow cause the formation of large, iridescent soap bubbles that can stretch and elongate into complex shapes.", "rule_support_query": "The woman in the QUERY video uses a large wand to draw soap solution, creating multiple large bubbles that float and stretch in the air, demonstrating the same physical process of bubble formation via surface tension and air movement.", "rule_support_demo": "In the DEMO video, a person uses a large frame to generate a long, flowing bubble structure that stretches across the field, with smaller bubbles forming at the end, clearly showing the same mechanism of soap film stretching under tension and air flow.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY video features multiple smaller, interconnected bubbles created with a wand, while the DEMO video shows a single, elongated bubble structure created with a large frame; however, both rely on the same underlying physical principles of soap film formation and surface tension."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_be5029da718edc9a0c49.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_15373fe81deeb93a8b53", "query_id": "a6d28859ed3b97622858ea92f82b954ac41b2bc0af0b740824bd276b73d20ccd", "demo_id": "8d0594937630d2e2889737f71af806973a35bc4fd6000cb0a77d6f9384b8f9fa", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/a6d28859ed3b97622858ea92f82b954ac41b2bc0af0b740824bd276b73d20ccd.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/8d0594937630d2e2889737f71af806973a35bc4fd6000cb0a77d6f9384b8f9fa.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_15373fe81deeb93a8b53", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_surface"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_surface": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.85, "process_sim": 0.882, "role_overlap": 1.0, "rule_score": 4.5, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A stack of white plastic bowls is crushed by a descending hydraulic press, shattering into fragments that scatter outward.", "demo_event": "A single beige ceramic or porcelain ball is crushed by a descending hydraulic press, breaking into multiple pieces that fly outward.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a brittle or rigid object is subjected to sudden, high compressive force from a hydraulic press, it fractures and fragments, with pieces propelled outward due to stored elastic energy and momentum.", "rule_support_query": "The plastic bowls shatter and fragments fly outward upon impact with the press, indicating brittle fracture under compression.", "rule_support_demo": "The ball breaks into many pieces that scatter in all directions, showing similar brittle fracture under compressive force.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in material (plastic vs. ceramic) and shape (stacked bowls vs. sphere), but both exhibit brittle fracture under compression."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_15373fe81deeb93a8b53.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_f31cc686990568885563", "query_id": "7bac2948368648bd9c870e3df8c70e22dfbf0d08a1f9daaab5b64d5cc807c14c", "demo_id": "0fd409882cf1c8971568faa710d60f3dfeeacad9290af52317b1ffa64c409bfe", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/7bac2948368648bd9c870e3df8c70e22dfbf0d08a1f9daaab5b64d5cc807c14c.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/0fd409882cf1c8971568faa710d60f3dfeeacad9290af52317b1ffa64c409bfe.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_f31cc686990568885563", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.5076, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A tire with a red rim is compressed vertically by a hydraulic press, causing it to deform and flatten under pressure.", "demo_event": "An orange is compressed vertically between two metal plates of a hydraulic press, causing it to deform and eventually burst.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a deformable object is subjected to increasing vertical compressive force from a hydraulic press, it undergoes plastic deformation and flattens, with the extent of deformation depending on material properties and applied pressure.", "rule_support_query": "The tire visibly deforms and flattens as the press descends, showing progressive compression and bulging of the sides, consistent with material yielding under load.", "rule_support_demo": "The orange visibly compresses and flattens under the press, with its surface bulging outward and eventually rupturing, demonstrating material failure under increasing pressure.", "critical_difference": "The tire is a rigid structure with a solid rim and thick rubber, while the orange is a soft, fluid-filled fruit; however, both exhibit similar compressive deformation under the same type of applied force."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_f31cc686990568885563.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_0d4eafea13c5a1fe5ef7", "query_id": "2a70a33c23a398c7196410b6c5e0fac216f287583bd71d724b2053476aca3e8d", "demo_id": "50bdb084a21bd00b36bbcc30dc1d8d077d338ba58c627f4fe7f1744ec099924c", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/2a70a33c23a398c7196410b6c5e0fac216f287583bd71d724b2053476aca3e8d.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/50bdb084a21bd00b36bbcc30dc1d8d077d338ba58c627f4fe7f1744ec099924c.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_0d4eafea13c5a1fe5ef7", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.0788, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press crushes a pile of white, brittle fragments, causing them to shatter and disintegrate into smaller pieces with visible dust and debris.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press compresses a block of white, fibrous material, causing it to crumble and break apart into fine particles and dust.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a large, downward force is applied by a hydraulic press to a brittle or fibrous material, the material undergoes compressive failure, fracturing and disintegrating into smaller fragments and dust.", "rule_support_query": "The hydraulic press descends onto white fragments, which shatter and produce dust and debris as the press continues to apply force, indicating compressive failure.", "rule_support_demo": "The hydraulic press descends onto a white fibrous block, which crumbles and breaks apart into fine particles and dust under the applied force, demonstrating compressive failure.", "critical_difference": "The initial material in QUERY appears to be brittle fragments (possibly ceramic or plastic), while in DEMO it is a cohesive fibrous block (possibly insulation or foam), but both respond similarly to compressive force by fracturing and disintegrating."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_0d4eafea13c5a1fe5ef7.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_7ccd5bf36803bffb119b", "query_id": "81f66251c5f4d477179070e4ee5c9b0c3c85b5224bcce1dce0697a0197e327bd", "demo_id": "ced0e189f387834be0a4f4a4f2b9bca0fb7825f083fbc0a1ab17123e4a6e6b28", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/81f66251c5f4d477179070e4ee5c9b0c3c85b5224bcce1dce0697a0197e327bd.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/ced0e189f387834be0a4f4a4f2b9bca0fb7825f083fbc0a1ab17123e4a6e6b28.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_7ccd5bf36803bffb119b", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.3116, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "Two cylindrical blocks of pink and blue material are compressed vertically by a hydraulic press, causing them to deform and flatten under pressure.", "demo_event": "A green, irregularly shaped object is compressed vertically by a hydraulic press, causing it to deform and spread outward under pressure.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a compressible material is subjected to vertical pressure from a hydraulic press, it deforms plastically, reducing in height and spreading laterally.", "rule_support_query": "The pink and blue blocks visibly compress and flatten under the descending press, with lateral spreading observed as the height decreases.", "rule_support_demo": "The green object visibly deforms and spreads outward as the press descends, reducing in height and increasing in lateral dimensions.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in shape and color, but both are compressible materials undergoing similar deformation under vertical pressure."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_7ccd5bf36803bffb119b.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_9ed68654ff647bdaa59f", "query_id": "00a67d73b010d32554ec6365bde6272c447475a2f0ca01d187c2d13045cf2e43", "demo_id": "e53ea251d7992c393c18055626893b95d17a7fc40e2aee55419a9a80ee21e0df", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/00a67d73b010d32554ec6365bde6272c447475a2f0ca01d187c2d13045cf2e43.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/e53ea251d7992c393c18055626893b95d17a7fc40e2aee55419a9a80ee21e0df.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_9ed68654ff647bdaa59f", "mining_intents": ["hard_object"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 1.219, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A person uses a knife and fork to cut into a French toast dish topped with powdered sugar, bananas, and strawberries on a yellow plate.", "demo_event": "A person uses a knife and fork to cut into a French toast dish topped with powdered sugar, bananas, and strawberries on a yellow plate.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a person applies downward force with a knife and fork on a solid food item (like French toast) placed on a plate, the food deforms and separates along the cut line, allowing it to be divided into smaller portions.", "rule_support_query": "The knife is pressed into the French toast while the fork holds it steady, causing a visible cut to form and the food to separate slightly.", "rule_support_demo": "The knife is pressed into the French toast while the fork holds it steady, causing a visible cut to form and the food to separate slightly.", "critical_difference": "No critical difference observed; both videos show identical actions, objects, and outcomes."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_9ed68654ff647bdaa59f.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_bb78e8b0697873a61ee1", "query_id": "1ff9234f37fa66aa3f0dbca617102d3c795983f8a209167151d6a4befd3c129f", "demo_id": "964b95c72f4e09e561c94d0799be282ea81912846c607f9a3d6992d8005fc4e0", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "mechanism_only_candidate", "review_flags": ["specific_response_not_matched"], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/1ff9234f37fa66aa3f0dbca617102d3c795983f8a209167151d6a4befd3c129f.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/964b95c72f4e09e561c94d0799be282ea81912846c607f9a3d6992d8005fc4e0.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_bb78e8b0697873a61ee1", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.6698, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press with black and yellow striped sides descends onto a small green object, compressing it between the press and a matching striped base.", "demo_event": "A large hydraulic press descends onto a coiled metal spring placed on a black and yellow striped base, compressing the spring until it is flattened.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "different", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a hydraulic press applies downward force onto an object placed on a rigid base, the object undergoes compression or deformation proportional to the applied force and its material properties.", "rule_support_query": "The green object visibly deforms and flattens as the press descends, indicating compression under force.", "rule_support_demo": "The metal spring visibly compresses and flattens as the press descends, demonstrating compression under force.", "critical_difference": "The objects being compressed are different in material and structure (green object vs. metal spring), leading to different deformation behaviors, but the underlying physical mechanism of compression under applied force remains the same."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_bb78e8b0697873a61ee1.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_1d1319cd47948fb26396", "query_id": "574bfa29d2e93519488f4f02e4c55fce5e0a24fb80e3a8d322c73e854b7040b7", "demo_id": "6ebc90d35375d1172f9c3a92d5f69b23f4189bd81d5fff3123959f07715c5076", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/574bfa29d2e93519488f4f02e4c55fce5e0a24fb80e3a8d322c73e854b7040b7.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/6ebc90d35375d1172f9c3a92d5f69b23f4189bd81d5fff3123959f07715c5076.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_1d1319cd47948fb26396", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.6893, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A black rubber shoe is compressed and deformed under a descending metal press, causing it to rupture and disintegrate.", "demo_event": "A metal hydraulic press crushes a wooden object, causing it to splinter and fragment explosively with debris scattering.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid, heavy object applies sustained downward force onto a less rigid, brittle or ductile material, the material undergoes deformation and eventually fails, fracturing or rupturing under stress.", "rule_support_query": "The metal press descends onto the shoe, which deforms and then ruptures, with material breaking apart and fragments falling away, indicating failure under compressive force.", "rule_support_demo": "The hydraulic press descends onto the wooden object, which splinters and breaks apart explosively, with debris scattering, indicating failure under compressive force.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ (rubber vs. wood), but both are non-metallic and fail under compression; the query shows ductile tearing while the demo shows brittle fragmentation, yet both are consistent with the same physical rule of material failure under sustained compressive load."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_1d1319cd47948fb26396.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_6f579fceb2c47801e891", "query_id": "16ff02e2cd303840c396a45b323d5c9824a8324c7d97301182d99847bc2537e2", "demo_id": "67eb28b8a184e9be6c596a4491307511cb95cb90536a4f35bb6e05d02c91b395", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "onset", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/16ff02e2cd303840c396a45b323d5c9824a8324c7d97301182d99847bc2537e2.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/67eb28b8a184e9be6c596a4491307511cb95cb90536a4f35bb6e05d02c91b395.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_6f579fceb2c47801e891", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.5325, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A knife cuts through a blue sponge, creating a grid of slits, then moves to cut a pink sponge in the same manner.", "demo_event": "A person uses a knife to slice a loaf of bread into even pieces on a wooden cutting board.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "Applying a cutting force with a sharp blade through a deformable material results in separation along the cut path, with the material deforming and parting cleanly if the blade is sufficiently sharp and the material is not overly resistant.", "rule_support_query": "The knife cuts cleanly through the sponges, creating precise slits without tearing, indicating the blade's sharpness and the sponges' soft, porous structure allowing for clean separation.", "rule_support_demo": "The knife slices through the bread with minimal resistance, producing clean, even pieces, demonstrating the same cutting mechanism on a different deformable material.", "critical_difference": "The materials differ in composition and density (sponge vs. bread), but both are soft and allow for clean cutting with a sharp blade, supporting the same physical rule."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_6f579fceb2c47801e891.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_855c7d2220925bc04d2a", "query_id": "53744f9af9c40613099571a08746906fbae24de3eff1c3656780a4dcfc167796", "demo_id": "227d46e44fb81cfdf00757ffd174110e656e1c7a15561372967915dc9ed9bb47", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/53744f9af9c40613099571a08746906fbae24de3eff1c3656780a4dcfc167796.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/227d46e44fb81cfdf00757ffd174110e656e1c7a15561372967915dc9ed9bb47.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v1", "original_pair_id": "cr_855c7d2220925bc04d2a", "mining_intents": ["same_rule_cross_object_action"], "retrieval_features": {"same_rule_cross_object_action": {"motion_is_proxy_only": false, "object_sim": 0.761, "process_sim": 0.79, "role_overlap": 0.333, "rule_score": 4.0, "same_mechanism_family": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A white, cylindrical foam-like object is compressed vertically in a testing machine, deforming and eventually fracturing under increasing load, as shown by a real-time force-displacement graph on a monitor.", "demo_event": "A rectangular wooden beam is compressed vertically between two metal plates, buckling and deforming laterally as it fails under load, against a black background.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a material is subjected to compressive force exceeding its yield strength, it undergoes plastic deformation and eventually fails, with the mode of failure (fracture or buckling) depending on material properties and geometry.", "rule_support_query": "The foam object deforms and fractures under increasing load, with force and displacement data recorded in real time.", "rule_support_demo": "The wooden beam buckles and deforms laterally under compressive load, indicating failure due to instability.", "critical_difference": "The foam object fractures due to material failure, while the wooden beam buckles due to structural instability; both are compressive failure modes but differ in failure mechanism."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v1/cr_855c7d2220925bc04d2a.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_ea221283ebf799d90f55", "query_id": "eb066ee7214945f937d670b7dee8562745bf0326744fd1557653d50a91b282cf", "demo_id": "6937d41572945b46af3e3799831b94662c0c69b3f0e17fbc1d2971d52eecd0a7", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/eb066ee7214945f937d670b7dee8562745bf0326744fd1557653d50a91b282cf.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/6937d41572945b46af3e3799831b94662c0c69b3f0e17fbc1d2971d52eecd0a7.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_ea221283ebf799d90f55", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 7.6037, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hammer placed on a stack of black circular plates is crushed by a hydraulic press, causing the hammer to shatter and fragments to fly outward.", "demo_event": "A metallic mechanical component is crushed by a hydraulic press with a yellow and black striped ram, causing it to deform and break apart.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid object is subjected to high compressive force from a hydraulic press, it undergoes structural failure, resulting in fragmentation or deformation.", "rule_support_query": "The hammer, initially intact, is compressed by the descending press, leading to visible shattering and ejection of fragments, indicating structural failure under pressure.", "rule_support_demo": "The mechanical component, initially intact, is compressed by the descending press, leading to visible deformation and fragmentation, indicating structural failure under pressure.", "critical_difference": "The objects being crushed differ in material and structure (hammer vs. mechanical component), but both are rigid and fail under compression in a similar manner."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_ea221283ebf799d90f55.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_e377be08e511cd26e64e", "query_id": "bac0bec2b1e2528a5a7bed91529cd1f57dc8017cad755a975de8b478fc60addd", "demo_id": "c91d3918b8345aa36b02acd2bf7382afa24e6df11c585eb157dc0fd7662611b9", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "optical_interaction", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/bac0bec2b1e2528a5a7bed91529cd1f57dc8017cad755a975de8b478fc60addd.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/c91d3918b8345aa36b02acd2bf7382afa24e6df11c585eb157dc0fd7662611b9.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_e377be08e511cd26e64e", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.6867, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hand holds and rotates an oval opal gemstone, causing its internal iridescent colors to shift and change under light.", "demo_event": "A hand holds and rotates an oval opal gemstone, causing its internal iridescent colors to shift and change under light.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "similar", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "Rotating an opal gemstone under light causes its internal diffraction and interference of light to produce shifting iridescent colors, dependent on viewing angle and light source.", "rule_support_query": "The opal's colors dynamically change from green, blue, orange, and red as it is rotated between fingers, indicating angle-dependent light interference.", "rule_support_demo": "The opal's colors shift similarly from green, yellow, pink, and blue as it is rotated, demonstrating the same angle-dependent optical phenomenon.", "critical_difference": "No critical difference observed; both videos show identical physical behavior of the same type of object under similar manipulation and lighting conditions."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_e377be08e511cd26e64e.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_3f569a7f364cf12975cc", "query_id": "67cc319d7e4ee64d8da328d3ffd630ef775d162e213dcec2d06ba633e001dbed", "demo_id": "e52a525887e71a56f31081f5fd4d63144e87497a9ceb775f21a7f6155fb55631", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "deformation", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/67cc319d7e4ee64d8da328d3ffd630ef775d162e213dcec2d06ba633e001dbed.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/e52a525887e71a56f31081f5fd4d63144e87497a9ceb775f21a7f6155fb55631.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_3f569a7f364cf12975cc", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 11.0038, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press with a black and yellow striped cylinder compresses a stack of glass bottles and a red object on a matching striped base, causing visible deformation and cracking of the glass.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press with a yellow and black striped cylinder compresses a silver, foil-wrapped object on a matching striped base, causing it to deform and spread outward under pressure.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a hydraulic press applies downward force onto an object placed on a rigid base, the object deforms or fractures under compressive stress, with the extent and nature of deformation depending on the object's material properties.", "rule_support_query": "The glass bottles visibly crack and compress under the press, indicating material failure under pressure, consistent with brittle deformation.", "rule_support_demo": "The foil-wrapped object spreads and flattens under the press, indicating ductile deformation, consistent with compressive stress response.", "critical_difference": "The materials of the compressed objects differ significantly (glass vs. foil-wrapped material), leading to different deformation behaviors (brittle fracture vs. ductile spreading), but both respond to the same compressive force mechanism."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_3f569a7f364cf12975cc.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_3e7169672a1ea18079c1", "query_id": "8d0594937630d2e2889737f71af806973a35bc4fd6000cb0a77d6f9384b8f9fa", "demo_id": "a6d28859ed3b97622858ea92f82b954ac41b2bc0af0b740824bd276b73d20ccd", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "pre_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_007/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/7/8d0594937630d2e2889737f71af806973a35bc4fd6000cb0a77d6f9384b8f9fa.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_106/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/106/a6d28859ed3b97622858ea92f82b954ac41b2bc0af0b740824bd276b73d20ccd.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_3e7169672a1ea18079c1", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 10.1817, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A white spherical object is crushed by a hydraulic press, shattering into fragments and debris.", "demo_event": "A stack of white plastic bowls is crushed by a hydraulic press, breaking into pieces and scattering fragments.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a rigid or brittle object is subjected to high compressive force from a hydraulic press, it fractures and breaks into multiple pieces due to material failure under stress.", "rule_support_query": "The white sphere shatters instantly upon contact with the descending press, producing flying fragments and dust, indicating brittle fracture under compression.", "rule_support_demo": "The stack of plastic bowls deforms and then fractures under the press, with pieces breaking off and scattering, demonstrating brittle failure under compressive load.", "critical_difference": "The objects differ in shape (sphere vs. stacked bowls) and material (likely ceramic or eggshell vs. plastic), but both exhibit brittle fracture under similar compressive force from a hydraulic press."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_3e7169672a1ea18079c1.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_339f8f0918fa52bfcd4e", "query_id": "38ae9b0cdbf7d410f4364491b45a121b50316e233cf303a95ceced45ec250f86", "demo_id": "363d1fd5454d9513fde9e32fc856876e0fcafc5f83227ce796f8c8cbcfaa93e7", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["cross_surface", "positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "fracture_separation", "source_phase": "mid_event", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/38ae9b0cdbf7d410f4364491b45a121b50316e233cf303a95ceced45ec250f86.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_alpha3_pool/shard_018/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/18/363d1fd5454d9513fde9e32fc856876e0fcafc5f83227ce796f8c8cbcfaa93e7.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_339f8f0918fa52bfcd4e", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 8.2031, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive", "cross_surface"], "assessment": {"query_event": "A hydraulic press crushes a transparent cylindrical object, causing it to shatter explosively with fragments and white vapor dispersing outward.", "demo_event": "A hydraulic press compresses a cylindrical object wrapped in black-and-yellow striped tape, causing it to fracture and crumble into small pieces with white powder and debris.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "different", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When a cylindrical object is subjected to high compressive force from a hydraulic press, it undergoes structural failure, resulting in fragmentation and dispersal of material.", "rule_support_query": "The transparent cylinder shatters under the press, with visible fragments and vapor indicating material failure and release of internal pressure or contents.", "rule_support_demo": "The striped cylinder fractures and crumbles under the press, with debris and powder indicating material breakdown under compression.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY object is transparent and appears to contain or release vapor, suggesting possible internal pressure or chemical reaction, while the DEMO object is opaque and produces only powder and solid debris, indicating a purely mechanical failure without visible vapor or gas release."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_339f8f0918fa52bfcd4e.json"}]}
+{"pair_id": "cr_88db3a3e00852ed445e3", "query_id": "0ca7d3bbacd09736d229c6971e18f644dac124fd77aecb5688bffb88fa7d6ac1", "demo_id": "9050c3d0a02ff9f39468d61863c1ad4e7f8fbbca64914426ab7875f498dbbe78", "split": "train", "response_transfer_status": "response_compatible_candidate", "review_flags": [], "original_tags": ["positive"], "verified_by_human": false, "screening_basis": "existing model judgments only; no new visual verification", "physics_family": "phase_transition", "source_phase": "continuous", "query_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_add3000/shard_029/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/29/0ca7d3bbacd09736d229c6971e18f644dac124fd77aecb5688bffb88fa7d6ac1.mp4", "demo_video": "data/wisa80k/extracted_scaleup3000/shard_105/home/jovyan/maao-data-cephfs-3/workspace/maao/projects/huggingface/videos/128_split/105/9050c3d0a02ff9f39468d61863c1ad4e7f8fbbca64914426ab7875f498dbbe78.mp4", "source_train_ready": false, "source_pair_assessments": [{"source": "v2", "original_pair_id": "cr_88db3a3e00852ed445e3", "mining_intents": ["positive"], "retrieval_features": {"rule_mining_v2": {"score": 9.0069, "source_split": "train", "hypothesis_only": true}}, "labels": ["positive"], "assessment": {"query_event": "Water boiling vigorously in a cast iron pan on a gas stove, producing steam and bubbles.", "demo_event": "Pasta boiling in water in a metal pot, with bubbles and steam indicating active boiling.", "shared_rule": "yes", "rule_applicability_to_query": "applicable", "object_similarity": "different", "action_similarity": "similar", "motion_similarity": "similar", "surface_similarity": "similar", "mechanism_similarity": "similar", "outcome_relation": "similar", "primary_event_alignment": "matched", "physical_rule": "When water is heated above its boiling point in an open container, it undergoes phase transition to steam, producing bubbles and visible vapor, regardless of the container material or contents (as long as the water is present and heated sufficiently).", "rule_support_query": "The video shows water in a pan on a gas flame, with visible bubbles and steam, indicating boiling. The pan is hot, and the water is actively transitioning to vapor.", "rule_support_demo": "The video shows pasta in water with vigorous bubbling and steam, confirming boiling. The water is heated, and the phase change to steam is evident.", "critical_difference": "The QUERY video contains only water, while the DEMO video contains pasta in water. However, the boiling mechanism remains the same; the presence of pasta does not alter the fundamental physical process of water boiling."}, "cache_path": "experiments/causal_icl/rule_groups_v1/vlm_reviews/rule_vlm_4fps_v2/cr_88db3a3e00852ed445e3.json"}]}